| 0 | Sabrina's Christmas Magic | cover | 1 | pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Rudy Lapick; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Aunt Hilda; Cousin Ambrose; Aunt Zelda |
| 1 | Hidden Claus | comic story | 10 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Aunt Hilda; Santa Claus; Aku |
| 2 | Sabrina's Wrap Session | comic story | 1 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Jughead Jones |
| 3 | Sweet Words | comic story | 1 | script: Joe Edwards; pencils: Joe Edwards; inks: Joe Edwards; letters: Joe Edwards | Li'l Jinx Holliday; Hap Holliday |
| 4 | Hot Dog With Relish | comic story | 6 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Hot Dog; Ethel Muggs; Reggie Mantle; Archie Andrews; Jughead Jones; Pop Tate |
| 5 | Aunt Hilda's Beauty Secrets | comic story | 1 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Aunt Hilda |
| 6 | The Spell of the Season | comic story | 10 | script: Frank Doyle; pencils: Stan Goldberg; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Aunt Hilda; Della; Harvey Kinkle; Archie Andrews; Betty Cooper; Jughead Jones |
| 7 | What Does Christmas Mean To You? | comic story | 2 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Veronica Lodge; Mr. Lodge; Moose Mason; Reggie Mantle; Hot Dog; Archie Andrews; Waldo Weatherbee; Jughead Jones; Betty Cooper |
| 8 | Sabrina's Instant Christmas Decorations | comic story | 1 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman |
| 9 | Sabrina Answers Questions About Christmas | text article | 2 | script: Joe Edwards; pencils: Joe Edwards; inks: Joe Edwards; letters: Joe Edwards | Sabrina Spellman |
| 10 | Picture That! | comic story | 1 | script: Joe Edwards; pencils: Joe Edwards; inks: Joe Edwards; letters: Joe Edwards | Li'l Jinx Holliday; Gigi |
| 11 | Mission Possible | comic story | 6 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Aunt Hilda |
| 12 | Popcorn Poopsie | comic story | 1 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Jughead Jones |
| 13 | Animal Crackers | comic story | 8 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Waldo Weatherbee; Veronica Lodge; Moose Mason; Reggie Mantle; Archie Andrews; Jughead Jones; Dilton Doily |
| 14 | Sabrina Keeps in Christmas Trim | comic story | 2 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman |
| 15 | Sabrina's Witch Wisher! | comic story | 2 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Al Hartley; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Veronica Lodge; Archie Andrews; Moose Mason; Reggie Mantle; Waldo Weatherbee; Pop Tate; Jughead Jones; Geraldine Grundy; Miss Haggly; Mr. Svenson; Dilton Doily |
| 16 | A Tree Named Obadiah | comic story | 12 | script: Frank Doyle; pencils: Stan Goldberg; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman; Archie Andrews; Betty Cooper; Veronica Lodge; Mr. Lodge; Smithers; Chuck Clayton; Aunt Hilda; Aunt Zelda; Cousin Ambrose; Della; Obadiah |
| 17 | Sabrina Pin-Up | comic story | 1 | script: Al Hartley; pencils: Al Hartley; inks: Joe Sinnott; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Sabrina Spellman, Mr. Weatherbee |