| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: John Lucas; inks: John Lucas; letters: Bill Yoshida | Katy Keene |
| 1 | Katy's Incredible Secret! (Part 1) | comic story | 6 | script: Susan Berkley; pencils: John Lucas; inks: Mike Esposito; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Katy Keene; Gloria Granbilt; Mr. Keene (Dad in dream); Mrs. Keene (Mom in dream); Melissa Keene [Sis]; Sam Phillips |
| 2 | Katy's Incredible Secret! (Part 2) | comic story | 5 | script: Susan Berkley; pencils: John Lucas; inks: Mike Esposito; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Katy Keene; Mrs. Keene (Mom in dream); Melissa Keene [Sis]; Gloria Granbilt |
| 3 | Katy Reads Your Zodiac Signs | text article | 2 | pencils: John Lucas; inks: John Lucas; colors: Barry Grossman | Katy Keene |
| 4 | You Don't Need Drugs To... | public service announcement | 1 | | Archie Andrews; Betty Cooper; Jughead Jones; Reggie Mantle; Chuck Clayton; Veronica Lodge; Moose Mason; Dilton Doiley; Hotdog |
| 5 | A Day With Katy... | comic story | 1 | pencils: John Lucas; inks: John Lucas; colors: Barry Grossman | Katy Keene |
| 6 | Valentine Crossword Puzzle | activity | 0.5 | | Katy Keene |
| 7 | Katy and Sis Go Shopping | illustration | 1 | script: John S. Lucas; pencils: John Lucas; inks: John Lucas; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: John Lucas | Katy Keene; Melissa Keene [Sis] |
| 8 | Letters to Katy | letters page | 1 | pencils: John Lucas; inks: John Lucas | Katy Keene |
| 9 | Katie's Valentine Vogues | activity | 2 | pencils: John Lucas; inks: John Lucas; colors: Barry Grossman | Katy Keene |
| 10 | Oh, Brother! | comic story | 3 | | Katy Keene; Melissa Keene [Sis]; Lucki Red Lorelei; Spike Lorelei |
| 11 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 12 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 13 | Fans! Now You Can Join the Exciting Katy Keene Fan Club! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: John S. Lucas | Katy Keene |