| 0 | Sabrina the Teenage Witch | cover | 1 | pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo; colors: Barry Grossman | Aunt Hilda, Aunt Zelda, Sabrina Spellman |
| 2 | Do You Believe in Magic (Chapter 1) | comic story | 6 | script: Dan Parent; pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Aunt Hilda, Aunt Zelda, Harvey Kinkle, Mr. Weatherbee, Sabrina Spellman |
| 4 | Fan Art | letters page | 1 | pencils: Ellen Leonforte; inks: Ellen Leonforte; colors: Barry Grossman | |
| 5 | Do You Believe in Magic (Chapter 2) | comic story | 5 | script: Dan Parent; pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Aunt Hilda, Aunt Zelda, Harvey Kinkle, Salem Saberhagen, Sabrina Spellman |
| 6 | - | in-house column | 1 | script: Victor Gorelick; pencils: Ellen Leonforte; inks: Ellen Leonforte | |
| 8 | The Three Witches of Riverdale: Fashions | illustration | 2 | script: Dan Parent; pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Aunt Hilda, Aunt Zelda, Sabrina Spellman |
| 9 | Cheryl Blossom Multi Subscription Offer | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Dan Parent | Cheryl Blossom; Archie; Betty; Veronica |
| 10 | Do You Believe in Magic (Chapter 3) | comic story | 5 | script: Dan Parent; pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Aunt Hilda, Aunt Zelda, Sabrina Spellman |
| 11 | Archie Subscription Offer | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | | |
| 12 | Meet Melissa Joan Hart Starring as Sabrina the Teenaged Witch on ABC-TV! | text article | 1 | script: Victor Gorelick; pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo | Sabrina Spellman |
| 13 | Archie Volleyball T-Shirt Offer | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | | Betty Cooper |
| 14 | Do You Believe in Magic (Chapter 4) | comic story | 5 | script: Dan Parent; pencils: Dan DeCarlo; inks: Dan DeCarlo; colors: Barry Grossman; letters: Bill Yoshida | Archie Andrews, Aunt Hilda, Aunt Zelda, Betty Cooper, Miss Grundy, Jughead Jones, Harvey Kinkle, Reggie Mantle, Mr. Weatherbee, Sabrina Spellman |
| 15 | Archie's Subscription Offer | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: ? (illustrations); inks: ? (illustrations); colors: ? (illustrations); letters: typeset | Betty Cooper; Archie Andrews |
| 16 | - | public service announcement | 1 | | Jughead Jones |