| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Ty Templeton; inks: Ty Templeton; colors: Ty Templeton; letters: Todd Klein | Batman, Tim Drake, The Flash, Green Lantern, Clark Kent, Lightning Lad, Princess Diana, Garth Ranzz, Kyle Rayner, Robin, Superman, Bruce Wayne, Wally West, Wonder Woman |
| 1 | A DC Universe Christmas | table of contents | 4 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | Wanted: Santa Claus -- Dead or Alive! | comic story | 10 | script: Denny O'Neil; pencils: Frank Miller; inks: Steve Mitchell; colors: Glynis Wein; letters: Ben Oda; editing: Joe Orlando, Len Wein | Batman, Bruce Wayne |
| 3 | Present Tense | comic story | 8 | script: Mark Waid, Brian Augustyn; pencils: Paul Ryan; inks: Dick Giordano; colors: Tom McCraw; letters: John Costanza; editing: Darren Vincenzo | The Flash, Linda Park West, Wally West |
| 4 | The Story of Fir Balsam | comic story | 13 | script: Charles Moulton; pencils: Harry G. Peter; inks: Harry G. Peter; editing: Sheldon Mayer | Princess Diana, Steve Trevor, Wonder Woman |
| 5 | The Gift | comic story | 3 | script: Dan Jurgens; pencils: Dan Jurgens; inks: Brett Breeding; colors: Jason Wright; letters: John Costanza; editing: Darren Vincenzo | Clark Kent, Superman |
| 6 | A Swingin' Christmas Carol! | comic story | 21.5 | script: Bob Haney; pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy; colors: Helen Vesik; letters: Joe Letterese; editing: George Kashdan | Aqualad, Garth, Dick Grayson, Kid Flash, Robin, Donna Troy, Wally West, Wonder Girl |
| 7 | Present Tense | comic story | 2 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Ty Templeton; inks: Ty Templeton; colors: Ty Templeton; letters: Ty Templeton; editing: Darren Vincenzo | Darkseid |
| 8 | Billy Batson's Xmas | comic story | 7 | script: Otto Binder; pencils: C. C. Beck, Pete Costanza, Beck-Costanza Studio; inks: C. C. Beck, Pete Costanza, Beck-Costanza Studio; editing: Wendell Crowley | Captain Marvel, Captain Marvel Jr., Mary Marvel, Uncle Dudley, Uncle Marvel |
| 9 | Alone for the Holidays | comic story | 4 | script: Chuck Dixon; pencils: Gordon Purcell; inks: Danny Miki; colors: Noelle Giddings; letters: Clem Robins; editing: Darren Vincenzo, Joseph Illidge | Barbara Gordon, Stephanie Brown, Tim Drake, Dick Grayson, Nightwing, Oracle, Alfred Pennyworth, Red Robin, Spoiler |
| 10 | Star Light, Star Bright... Farthest Star I See Tonight! | comic story | 12 | script: Paul Levitz; pencils: José Luis García-López; inks: Dick Giordano; colors: Adrienne Roy; letters: Ben Oda; editing: Joe Orlando, Len Wein | Gim Allon, Imra Ardeen, Val Armorr, Chameleon Boy, Colossal Boy, Reep Daggle, Karate Kid, Lightning Lad, Mon-El, Dirk Morgna, Phantom Girl, Princess Projectra, Garth Ranzz, Saturn Girl |
| 11 | The Present | comic story | 10 | script: Devin Grayson; pencils: Will Rosado; inks: Sal Buscema; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: John Costanza; editing: Darren Vincenzo | Green Lantern, Kyle Rayner |
| 13 | Night Prowler! | comic story | 4 | script: Len Wein; pencils: Bernie Wrightson, Howard Chaykin; inks: Bernie Wrightson, Howard Chaykin; letters: Milt Snapinn; editing: Joe Orlando, E. Nelson Bridwell | Cain |
| 15 | The Harley and the Ivy | comic story | 12 | script: Ronnie Del Carmen, Paul Dini; pencils: Ronnie Del Carmen; inks: Ronnie Del Carmen; colors: Ronnie Del Carmen; letters: Ronnie Del Carmen; editing: Scott Peterson, Darren Vincenzo | Harley Quinn; Poison Ivy; Batman |
| 16 | Santa Fronts for the Mob | comic story | 10 | script: Jack Kirby; pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Joe Simon; letters: Howard Ferguson; editing: Whitney Ellsworth | Wesley Dodds, Sandy Hawkins, The Sandman, Sandy the Golden Boy |
| 17 | An Eye for Detail | comic story | 4 | script: Chuck Dixon; pencils: Quique Alcatena; inks: Quique Alcatena; colors: Rick Taylor; letters: Clem Robins; editing: Darren Vincenzo, Joseph Illidge | Bat Lash |
| 18 | Silent Night | comic story | 8 | script: John Byrne; pencils: John Byrne; inks: Andy Kubert; colors: Glenn Whitmore; editing: Mark Waid | Enemy Ace [Hans von Hammer] |
| 19 | No, Bart, There Is No Santa Claus | comic story | 10 | script: Mark Waid, Devin Grayson; pencils: Craig Rousseau; inks: Mike Sellers; colors: Jason Scott Jones; letters: Clem Robins; editing: Darren Vincenzo, Joseph Illidge | Impulse |
| 20 | Superman's Christmas Adventure | comic story | 15 | script: Jerry Siegel; pencils: Jack Burnley; inks: Jack Burnley | Clark Kent, Lois Lane, Santa Claus, Superman, Perry White |