| 0 | Cheyenne Mystery! | cover | 1 | pencils: Alex Toth; inks: Joe Giella | Johnny Thunder |
| 1 | New As Tomorrow! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | | |
| 2 | Cheyenne Mystery! | comic story | 10 | script: Robert Kanigher; pencils: Alex Toth; inks: Joe Giella | Johnny Thunder [John Tane] |
| 4 | What to Do If Polio Comes Your Way | public service announcement | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 5 | Editorial Advisory Board | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 6 | Return of the Phantom Coach! | comic story | 8 | pencils: Gil Kane; inks: Bob Lander | Tony Barrett |
| 7 | Everybody - But Everybody Is Crazy about The Fox and the Crow | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | | Fauntleroy Fox; Crawford Crow |
| 8 | The Case of Billy the Kid's Gang! | comic story | 3 | pencils: Gil Kane; inks: John Giunta | |
| 9 | A Ticket to Boot Hill! | comic story | 8 | pencils: Irwin Hasen; inks: John Giunta | |
| 10 | Montana | comic story | 0.5 | script: Martin Naydel; pencils: Martin Naydel; inks: Martin Naydel; letters: Martin Naydel | |
| 12 | Western Facts | comic story | 0.67 | script: Martin Naydel; pencils: Martin Naydel; inks: Martin Naydel; letters: Martin Naydel | |
| 14 | The Gremlins of the Old West | text article | 2 | pencils: Raymond Perry; inks: Raymond Perry; colors: Raymond Perry | |
| 15 | The Charge of the Wagon Brigade! | comic story | 2 | script: Gardner Fox; pencils: John Giunta; inks: John Giunta | |
| 16 | Tinker Tom Shows You How to Become a "Western One-Man Band" | activity | 0.67 | | Tinker Tom |
| 18 | Mission to Outcast Ridge! | comic story | 8 | script: John Broome; pencils: Joe Kubert; inks: Joe Kubert | |
| 19 | Job Counselor | public service announcement | 1 | script: Jack Schiff; pencils: Curt Swan; inks: John Fischetti; letters: Ira Schnapp | |