| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Bob Smith; inks: Terry Beatty | Riddler; Robin [Tim Drake] |
| 1 | Chapter 1: The Oldest One in the Book! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bob Smith; inks: Terry Beatty | Nightwing; The Riddler; Batman |
| 2 | The Oldest One in the Book! | comic story | 22 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Tim Harkins | The Riddler; Commissioner Gordon; Nightwing; Batman; Harvey Bullock; Tim Drake [Robin] |
| 3 | Chapter 2: Notes | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bob Smith; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge | Batman; Robin [Tim Drake]; Nightwing; The Riddler |
| 4 | Notes | comic story | 22 | script: Scott Peterson; pencils: Tim Levins; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Tim Harkins | The Riddler; Batman; Robin [Tim Drake]; Nightwing |
| 5 | Chapter 3: Identity Theft | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bob Smith; inks: Terry Beatty | The Riddler |
| 6 | Identity Theft | comic story | 22 | script: Scott Peterson; pencils: Tim Levins; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Albert T. De Guzman | Batman; Robin [Tim Drake]; Commissioner Gordon; Riddler (villain); Clayface (Arkham cameo); Poison Ivy (Arkham cameo); Scarface (Arkham cameo); Ventriloquist (Arkham cameo); Killer Croc (Arkham cameo); Joker (Arkham cameo) |
| 7 | Chapter 4: The Real Deal | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bob Smith; inks: Terry Beatty | Riddler; Robin [Tim Drake] |
| 8 | The Real Deal | comic story | 22 | script: Scott Peterson; pencils: Tim Levins; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Albert T. De Guzman | Robin [Tim Drake]; Batman; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Alfred Pennyworth; Dick Grayson [Nightwing]; Commissioner Gordon; Riddler; Arkham Cameo: Joker |
| 9 | Chapter 5: Poker Face | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Kelsey Shannon; inks: Kelsey Shannon | Batman |
| 10 | Poker Face | comic story | 17 | script: Ty Templeton; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Rob Leigh | Batman; Riddler; Penguin; Alfred Pennyworth; Barbara Gordon [Batgirl](does not appear in costume in this issue); Robin [Tim Drake]; Commissioner James Gordon |
| 11 | Questions That Begin with a Queue | comic story | 5 | script: Dan Slott; pencils: Rick Burchett; inks: Terry Beatty; colors: Zylonol; letters: Rob Leigh | Riddler; Mr. Quarrel (Riddler's cook); Mr. Quizzley (servant); Batman (cameo) |
| 12 | Dear DC Super-Villains | preview (from the publisher) | 12 | script: Michael Northrop; pencils: Gustavo Duarte; inks: Gustavo Duarte; colors: Cris Peter; letters: Wes Abbott | |