| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Simon Bisley; inks: Simon Bisley; colors: Simon Bisley | |
| 1 | File 1: Judgment on Gotham | cover reprint (on interior page) | 2 | pencils: Simon Bisley; inks: Simon Bisley; colors: Simon Bisley | |
| 2 | - | comic story | 62 | script: Alan Grant, John Wagner; pencils: Simon Bisley; inks: Simon Bisley; colors: Simon Bisley; letters: Todd Klein | Mega-City One Judges [Psi Judge Anderson (guest); Judge Dredd [Joe Dredd] (featured)]; Mean Machine Angel (villain); Batman [Bruce Wayne] (featured); Judge Death (villain); Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane]; Hoganstein |
| 3 | File 2: The Ultimate Riddle | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Carl Critchlow; inks: Carl Critchlow; colors: Carl Critchlow | |
| 4 | - | comic story | 46 | script: Alan Grant, John Wagner; pencils: Carl Critchlow, Dermot Power; inks: Carl Critchlow, Dermot Power; colors: Carl Critchlow, Dermot Power; letters: Richard Starkings | Batman [Bruce Wayne] (featured); Judge Dredd [Joe Dredd] (featured); Riddler [Edward Nigma] (villain); Emperor Xero |
| 5 | File 3: Die Laughing | cover reprint (on interior page) | 2 | pencils: Jim Murray; inks: Jim Murray; colors: Jim Murray | |
| 6 | Part One | comic story | 46 | script: Alan Grant, John Wagner; pencils: Glenn Fabry, Jim Murray, Jason Brashill; inks: Glenn Fabry, Jim Murray, Jason Brashill; colors: Glenn Fabry, Jim Murray, Jason Brashill; letters: Ellie de Ville | Dark Judges [Judge Death (villain); Judge Fear (villain); Judge Fire (villain); Judge Mortis (villain)]; Mega-City One Judges [Psi Judge Anderson (guest); Judge Dredd [Joe Dredd] (featured); Deputy Chief Judge Herriman (death) (guest)]; Batman [Bruce Wayne] (featured); Joker (villain); Alfred Pennyw |
| 7 | Part Two | comic story | 46 | script: Alan Grant, John Wagner; pencils: Jim Murray; inks: Jim Murray; colors: Jim Murray; letters: Ellie de Ville | Dark Judges [Judge Death (villain); Judge Fear (villain); Judge Fire (villain); Judge Mortis (villain)]; Mega-City One Judges [Psi Judge Anderson (guest); Judge Dredd [Joe Dredd] (featured); Deputy Chief Judge Herriman (villain) (corpse, possessed by Judge Mortis)]; Batman [Bruce Wayne] (featured); |
| 8 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Glenn Fabry; inks: Glenn Fabry; colors: Glenn Fabry | |