| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: BIT; colors: Guy Major | Batman; Scarecrow; Man-Bat; Hush; Red Hood; Mr. Freeze; Clayface; Black Mask; Penguin; Killer Croc; Talia Head |
| 1 | Contents | table of contents | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | Strangers in Paradise | comic story | 17 | script: Bruce Jones; pencils: Eddy Barrows; inks: Jay Leisten; colors: Lee Loughridge; letters: Nick J. Napolitano | Batman [Bruce Wayne] (flashback); Nightwing [Dick Grayson] (flashback); Ezra Brownian; Red Hood [Jason Todd] (villain, flashback); David Sutabi (villain); Black Mask [Roman Sionis] (villain); Two-Face [Harvey Dent] (villain, flashback); Hush (villain, flashback); Tarantula [Catalina Flores] (villain |
| 3 | Black Mask | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: BIT; colors: Brad Anderson | Black Mask [Roman Sionis] |
| 4 | Killer Croc | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Ramón Bachs; inks: Ramón Bachs; colors: Jason Wright | Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Batman (only hand) |
| 5 | Penguin | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Cliff Chiang; inks: Cliff Chiang; colors: Cliff Chiang | Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; Batgirl [Cassandra Cain] |
| 6 | If a Man Be Clay! | comic story | 12 | script: Steve Purcell; pencils: Mike Mignola; inks: Kevin Nowlan; colors: Matt Hollingsworth; letters: John Workman; editing: Mark Waid, Bob Schreck | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; H. Bennington Screemore; Clayface [Matt Hagen] (villain) |
| 7 | Hush | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Al Barrionuevo; inks: BIT; colors: Brad Anderson | Hush [Tommy Elliot] |
| 8 | Red Hood | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Brad Walker; inks: Jimmy Palmiotti; colors: Lee Loughridge | Red Hood [Jason Todd; also as Robin]; Batman [also as Bruce Wayne]; Joker |
| 9 | Mr. Freeze | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: David López; inks: David López; colors: Giulia Brusco | Mr. Freeze [Victor Fries] |
| 10 | Man-Bat | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Mike Huddleston; inks: Mike Huddleston; colors: Lee Loughridge | Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom] |
| 11 | Daughters of the Demon | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Marcos Martín; inks: Marcos Martín; colors: Marcos Martín | Ra's al Ghul; Talia Head; Nyssa Raatko |
| 12 | Scarecrow | character profile | 1 | script: Andersen Gabrych; pencils: Sean Murphy; inks: Sean Murphy; colors: Lee Loughridge | Scarecrow [Jonathan Crane] |