| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson | Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Spectre |
| 1 | The Nature of Magic | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 3 | pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund | |
| 2 | Lightning Strikes Twice | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Beth Sotelo; letters: Richard Starkings | Superman; Bruce Gordon (cameo); Shazam; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Kenny Rip (cameo, dies); David Tellis (cameo, dies); Malcolm Diamond (cameo, dies); Commissioner Bill Henderson (cameo); Dr. Jeanine Tracey; Lois Lane; Dennis Kapri (cameo); Eclipso |
| 3 | Lightning Strikes Twice, Part 2 | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Beth Sotelo; letters: Richard Starkings | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Bruce Gordon; Lois Lane; Jimmy Olsen; Jeanine Tracey; Eclipso |
| 4 | Lightning Strikes Twice, Part 3 | comic story | 22 | script: Judd Winick; pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Beth Sotelo; letters: Richard Starkings | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Wizard Shazam; Spectre; Chester; Eclipso [Jean Loring] (bonds with Jean in final panel) |
| 5 | The World of Heroes and Sorcerers | character profile | 3 | pencils: Ron Wagner, Justiniano; inks: Dexter Vines, Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry | |
| 6 | Prologue: A Conversation in a Dark Place | comic story | 4 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Justiniano; inks: Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Eclipso [Jean Loring] |
| 7 | Chapter One: One Last Drink at the End of Time | comic story | 19 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Justiniano; inks: Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Eclipso [Jean Loring]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Enchantress [June Moon]; Blackbriar Thorn; Spectre; Nightshade [Eve Eden]; Arion; Animal Man [Buddy Baker]; Vixen; Black Orchid; Deadman; Jason Blood; hooded guy; Doctor Occult; Andrew Bennett; Jennifer Travis; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Blue Devil [Dan Cassi |
| 8 | Chapter Two: Some Enchantress Evening | comic story | 22 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Justiniano; inks: Livesay, Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Nightshade [Eve Eden]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Phantom Stranger; Eclipso [Jean Loring]; Spectre; Doctor Fate [Hector Hall] (cameo); Madame Xanadu (cameo) |
| 9 | Chapter Three: A Hot Night in Budapest | comic story | 22 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Ron Wagner; inks: Dexter Vines; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Nightshade [Eve Eden]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Phantom Stranger; Eclipso [Jean Loring]; Spectre; Green Lantern [Alan Scott] (cameo); Zatanna (cameo) |
| 10 | Chapter Four: Monkey Business | comic story | 21 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Justiniano; inks: Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Black Alice; Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Nightshade [Eve Eden]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Phantom Stranger; Eclipso [Jean Loring]; Spectre; Andrew Bennett (cameo); Black Adam (cameo); Captain Marvel, Jr. [Fredd |
| 11 | Chapter Five: The Particle Theory of Darkness | comic story | 22 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Justiniano; inks: Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Black Alice; Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon?]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Nightshade [Eve Eden]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Phantom Stranger; Shazam; Eclipso [Jean Loring]; Spectre |
| 12 | Chapter Six: The Death of Magic | comic story | 22 | script: Bill Willingham; pencils: Justiniano; inks: Walden Wong; colors: Chris Chuckry; letters: Pat Brosseau | Black Alice; Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon?]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Nightshade [Eve Eden]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Phantom Stranger; Shazam; Eclipso [Jean Loring]; Spectre |
| 13 | At the Oblivion Bar | text article | 2 | pencils: Justiniano; inks: Walden Wong | |
| 14 | Eclipso & Enchantress | illustration | 1 | pencils: Justiniano; inks: Justiniano; colors: Justiniano | |
| 15 | Action Comics 826 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Dave Stewart | Superman; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson] |
| 16 | Adventures of Superman 639 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Dave Stewart | Superman; Eclipso |
| 17 | Superman 216 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ian Churchill; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Dave Stewart | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Eclipso |
| 18 | Day of Vengeance 1 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson | Enchantress [June Moon]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Blackbriar Thorn; Spectre |
| 19 | Day of Vengeance 1 Second Printing | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson | Enchantress [June Moon]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Blackbriar Thorn; Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Nightshade [Eve Eden] |
| 20 | Day of Vengeance 2 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson; colors: Mike Atiyeh | Spectre |
| 21 | Day of Vengeance 3 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson | Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Spectre |
| 22 | Day of Vengeance 4 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson; colors: Mike Atiyeh | Enchantress [June Moon]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook] |
| 23 | Day of Vengeance 5 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson; colors: Mike Atiyeh | Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon?]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Spectre |
| 24 | Day of Vengeance 6 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Walter Simonson; inks: Walter Simonson; colors: Mike Atiyeh | Blue Devil [Dan Cassidy]; Detective Chimp; Enchantress [June Moon?]; Ragman [Rory Regan]; Nightmaster [Jim Rook]; Nightshade [Eve Eden] |