| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Riley Rossmo | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley] |
| 1 | - | credits, title page | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | Santa's Oath? | comic story | 10 | script: Dorado Quick; pencils: ML Sanapo; inks: ML Sanapo; colors: Arif Prianto; letters: Dave Sharpe; editing: Michael McCalister | Green Lantern [John Stewart]; Mrs. Claus [Carol]; Toyman [Winslow Schott] |
| 3 | Secret Santa | comic story | 10 | script: Drew Maxey; pencils: Marianna Ignazzi; inks: Marianna Ignazzi; colors: Giovanna Niro; letters: Pat Brosseau; editing: Katie Kubert | Secret Six [Bane; Catman [Thomas Blake]; Deadshot [Floyd Lawton]; Jeannette; Rag Doll [Peter Merkel, Jr.]; Scandal Savage] |
| 4 | Ghosts of Christmas Present | comic story | 10 | script: Ricardo Sánchez; pencils: Aaron Conley; inks: Aaron Conley; colors: Ivan Plascencia; letters: Steve Wands; editing: Andrew Marino | John Constantine; Abigail; Clarence; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 5 | It's a Criminal Life | comic story | 10 | script: Alexis Quasarano; pencils: Marcial Toledano Vargas; inks: Marcial Toledano Vargas; colors: Marcial Toledano Vargas; letters: Carlos M. Mangual; editing: Katie Kubert | The Joker; Robin [Jason Todd]; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Two-Face [Harvey Dent]; Joe Chill; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Martha Wayne; Thomas Wayne; Zorro |
| 6 | Deadman Walking | comic story | 10 | script: Marv Wolfman; pencils: Paul Pelletier; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Eren Angiolini; letters: Carlos M. Mangual; editing: Michael McCalister | Deadman [Boston Brand]; Angie; Beth; Dave; Greg |
| 7 | Silent Nite | comic story | 10 | script: James Reid; pencils: Francesco Francavilla; inks: Francesco Francavilla; letters: Dave Sharpe; editing: Katie Kubert | Doctor Mid-Nite [Charles McNider]; Hooty |
| 8 | The Perfect Gift | comic story | 10 | script: Zipporah Smith; pencils: Andrew Drilon; inks: Andrew Drilon; colors: Andrew Drilon; letters: Josh Reed; editing: Michael McCalister | Vixen [Mari McCabe]; Bronze Tiger [Benjamin Turner]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Wonder Girl [Donna Troy]; Livewire [Leslie Willis]; Abbie; Aztek [Nayeli Constant]; Extraño [Gregorio de la Vega]; Frost [Caitlin Snow]; Ray [Ray Terrill]; Shade the Changing Man [Rac Shade] |
| 9 | O Glowy Night | comic story | 10 | script: Calvin Kasulke; pencils: Anthony Marques; inks: Anthony Marques; colors: Wil Quintana; letters: Pat Brosseau; editing: Andrew Marino | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Jimmy Olsen; Lois Lane; Perry White; Lex Luthor; Mister Mxyzptlk; Parasite [Rudy Jones]; Toyman [Winslow Schott] |
| 10 | - | credits, title page | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 11 | - | illustration | 1 | | |