| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | |
| 1 | Identity Crisis Introduction | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 1 | script: Joss Whedon | |
| 2 | Dedications | text article | 1 | script: Brad Meltzer, Rags Morales | |
| 3 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | The Atom, Batman, Black Canary, Ralph Dibny, The Elongated Man, The Flash, Green Arrow, Carter Hall, Hawkman, Clark Kent, Dinah Lance, Ray Palmer, Princess Diana, Oliver Queen |
| 4 | Chapter One: Coffin | comic story | 38 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Nathaniel Adam, Bart Allen, Animal Man, Aquaman, Arsenal, The Atom, Buddy Baker, Ellen Baker, Billy Batson, Mary Batson, Beast Boy, Big Barda, Black Canary, Black Condor |
| 5 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Black Canary [Dinah Lance]; Flash [Barry Allen]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Lantern [Hal Jordan]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Zatanna |
| 6 | Chapter Two: House of Lies | comic story | 30 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Black Canary [Dinah Laurel Lance]; Elongated Man [Ralph Dibny]; Flash [Wally West; also as Kid Flash]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Lantern [Kyle Rayner]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Zatanna; Sue Dibny; Jean Loring; Doctor Mid-Nite [Pieter Cross]; Flash [Barry Allen]; Green Lanter |
| 7 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | Black Canary [Dinah Lance]; Flash [Wally West]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Lantern [Kyle Rayner]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Zatanna; Deathstroke |
| 8 | Chapter Three: Serial Killer | comic story | 30 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Black Canary [Dinah Laurel Lance]; Elongated Man [Ralph Dibny]; Flash [Wally West]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Lantern [Kyle Rayner]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Zatanna; Jack Drake; Jean Loring; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Owen Mercer (introduction); Jimmy Olsen; Robin [Tim Drake]; S |
| 9 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | Princess Diana, Wonder Woman |
| 10 | Chapter Four: Who Benefits | comic story | 30 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Black Canary [Dinah Laurel Lance]; Elongated Man [Ralph Dibny]; Flash [Wally West]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Jack Drake; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Jonathan Kent; Lois Lane; Owen Mercer; Mr. Miracle [Scott Free]; Oracle [Barbara Gordon]; Alfred Pennyworth; Robin [Tim Drake]; Spectre |
| 11 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | Tim Drake, Robin |
| 12 | Chapter Five: Father's Day | comic story | 30 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Flash [Wally West]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Lantern [Kyle Rayner]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Jack Drake; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Dr. Mid-Nite [Pieter Cross]; Firestorm [Ronnie Raymond]; Owen Mercer; Mr. Terrific [Michael Holt]; Oracle [Barbara G |
| 13 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 14 | Chapter Six: Husbands & Wives | comic story | 33 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Black Canary [Dinah Laurel Lance]; Ralph Dibny [Elongated Man]; Flash [Wally West]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Zatanna; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Clark Kent [Superman; Kal-El]; Dr. Mid-Nite [Pieter Cross]; Green Arrow [Connor Hawke]; Green Lantern [Hal Jordan]; |
| 15 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | |
| 16 | Chapter Seven: The Hero's Life | comic story | 30 | script: Brad Meltzer; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Ken Lopez | Atom [Ray Palmer]; Black Canary [Dinah Laurel Lance]; Ralph Dibny [Elongated Man]; Flash [Wally West]; Green Arrow [Oliver Queen]; Green Lantern [Kyle Rayner]; Hawkman [Carter Hall]; Zatanna; Animal Man [Buddy Baker]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Tim Drake [Robin]; Dick Grayson [Nightwing]; J'Onn J'Onzz; K |
| 17 | Casting Identity Crisis | text article | 1 | script: Rags Morales; pencils: Rags Morales; inks: Michael Bair | |
| 18 | Brad Meltzer and Rags Morales Dissect Identity Crisis | text article | 16 | script: Brad Meltzer, Rags Morales, Michael Bair, Ken Lopez, Alex Sinclair; pencils: Rags Morales, Michael Turner; inks: Michael Bair, Aspen MLT | |
| 19 | Variant Cover Gallery | cover reprint (on interior page) | 4 | pencils: Rags Morales, Michael Turner; inks: Michael Bair, Aspen MLT; colors: Peter Steigerwald | |
| 20 | Identity Crisis #1 Script | text story | 18 | script: Brad Meltzer | |
| 21 | Character Art by Michael Turner | illustration | 3 | pencils: Michael Turner; inks: Michael Turner | |
| 22 | Cover Sketches by Michael Turner | illustration | 3 | pencils: Michael Turner | |
| 23 | Biographies | text article | 1 | letters: typeset | |