| 0 | Year of the Villain - The Offer - Who Is Worthy of the Helmet of Fate? | cover | 1 | pencils: Guillem March; inks: Guillem March; colors: Arif Prianto | Justice League Dark [Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira]; Swamp Thing [Alec Holland]; Detective Chimp [Bobo]; Zatanna; Man-Bat [Kirk Langstrom]]; Doctor Fate (helmet only) |
| 2 | Chapter 1 The Last Lord of Order | comic story | 10 | script: James Tynion IV; pencils: Mark Buckingham; inks: Mick Gray; colors: Adriano Lucas; letters: Rob Leigh | Kent Nelson [as Doctor Fate in flashback]; Sven Nelson (flashback, death); Nabu (flashback); Khalid Nassour; Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira]; Khalis (flashback); Inza Nelson (flashback); |
| 6 | Chapter 2 Secrets & Origins | comic story | 8 | script: James Tynion IV; pencils: Daniel Sampere; inks: Juan Albarran; colors: Adriano Lucas; letters: Rob Leigh | John Constantine; Zatanna; Traci Thirteen; Zatara (flashback); Doctor Occult (flashback); Mento [Steve Dayton] (flashback); Baron Winters (flashback); Sargon the Sorceror [John Sargeant] (flashback, burning); Astra Logue (flashback); Anne-Marie (flashback); Judith (flashback); Frank (flashback); Ner |
| 7 | Batman Superman | promo (ad from the publisher) | 2 | pencils: David Marquez; inks: David Marquez | Superman [Clark Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Batman Who Laughs |
| 9 | Who Are the Infected? | promo (ad from the publisher) | 2 | | Batman Who Laughs; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Superman [Clark Kent]; Wonder Woman; Flash [Barry Allen]; Martian Manhunter; Mister Terrific; Robin [Damian Wayne]; Katana; Harley Quinn; Donna Troy; Blue Beetle; Hawkman; Beast Boy; John Constantine; Green Lantern [Hal Jordan]; Lobo; Captain Marvel [Billy Ba |
| 10 | Year of the Villain: Dark Gifts | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: various; inks: various; colors: various; letters: typeset | Superman; Lois Lane; Lex Luthor; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Mister Freeze [Victor Fries]; Flash [Barry Allen]; Wonder Woman; Hawkgirl; Martian Manhunter; Starro |
| 11 | Chapter 3 The Witching Way | comic story | 2 | script: James Tynion IV; pencils: Daniel Sampere; inks: Juan Albarran; colors: Adriano Lucas; letters: Rob Leigh | Circe; Lex Luthor |
| 12 | Wild Cats | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Jim Cheung | Savant [Kenesha]; Grifter [Cole Cash]; Void [Adrianna Tereshkova] |
| 14 | Interview with David Marquez | in-house column | 1 | script: David Marquez | |