| 0 | Christmas with the Super-Heroes | cover | 2 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy; colors: Sol Harrison; letters: Gaspar Saladino | Superman; Batman; Captain Marvel [billed as Shazam]; Teen Titans [Robin; Wonder Girl; Aqualad; Kid Flash]; Santa Claus |
| 1 | Contents | table of contents | 1 | script: Paul Levitz; pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | Superman; Batman; Captain Marvel; Teen Titans [Robin; Wonder Girl; Aqualad; Kid Flash]; Santa Claus |
| 2 | Silent Night, Deadly Night! | comic story | 17 | script: Denny O'Neil; pencils: Irv Novick; inks: Dick Giordano; letters: Ben Oda; editing: Julius Schwartz | Batman; Tim (last name unknown); Betsy (last name unknown); Richard Lee Evans; Santa Claus (as costume only) |
| 3 | Billy Batson's Xmas! | comic story | 7 | script: Otto Binder; pencils: C. C. Beck, Pete Costanza, Beck-Costanza Studio; inks: C. C. Beck, Pete Costanza, Beck-Costanza Studio; editing: Wendell Crowley | Santa Claus (as costume only); Captain Marvel [Billy Batson]; Captain Marvel, Jr. [Freddy Freeman]; Mary Marvel [Mary Batson]; Uncle Marvel [Uncle Dudley]; Sterling Morris; Mike (last name unknown); Ramberg (full name unknown) |
| 4 | The $500,000 Doll Caper! | comic story | 14.17 | script: John Albano; pencils: Bob Oksner; inks: Wally Wood; letters: Irv Watanabe; editing: Joe Orlando | Angel O'Day; Sam Simeon; Mr. Stooge; Boing [a Frankenstein/patchwork monster]; Mr. Stooge's crew [Duke; Scar; Dipp; unnamed men]; Santa Claus; Professor Sharpeyes |
| 5 | Christmas Quiz | activity | 0.33 | pencils: Curt Swan; inks: Murphy Anderson | Superman (head shot only) |
| 6 | Christmas Quiz II | activity | 0.5 | pencils: Mike Sekowsky; inks: Murphy Anderson | Batman |
| 7 | Super-Hero Calendar | illustration | 2 | pencils: Curt Swan, Neal Adams, C. C. Beck, Murphy Anderson, Gil Kane; inks: George Klein, Neal Adams, C. C. Beck, Murphy Anderson, Gil Kane | Superman; Batman; Captain Marvel; Wonder Woman; Green Arrow; Green Lantern; The Legion of Super-Heroes [Superboy; Lightning Lad; Cosmic Boy; Saturn Girl]; Hawkman; The Flash; Aquaman |
| 8 | A Swingin' Christmas Carol! | comic story | 21.5 | script: Bob Haney; pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy; letters: Joe Letterese; editing: George Kashdan | Teen Titans [Wonder Girl; Aqualad; Robin; Kid Flash]; Ebenezer Scrounge; Bob Ratchet; Tiny Tom Ratchet; Jacob Farley; Mr. Big (real name unknown); Mr. Big's unnamed crew |
| 9 | Christmas Quiz III | activity | 0.5 | | Captain Marvel (head shot only) |
| 10 | Christmas Quiz IV | activity | 0.5 | pencils: Irv Novick; inks: Dick Giordano | Robin (head shot only) |
| 11 | Christmas Quiz V | activity | 0.5 | inks: Bob Oksner; colors: Wally Wood | Angel O'Day |
| 12 | Christmastown, U. S. A.! | comic story | 12 | script: Al Schwartz; pencils: Win Mortimer, Vince Colletta; inks: Win Mortimer, Vince Colletta; letters: Ira Schnapp; editing: Whitney Ellsworth | Superman [Clark Kent]; Lois Lane; Perry White; Mr. Osborne (first name unknown); Danny Osborne; Santa Claus (as costume only) |
| 13 | A Stirring Christmas Story! | activity | 1 | script: Sheldon Mayer; pencils: Sheldon Mayer; inks: Sheldon Mayer; letters: Sheldon Mayer; editing: Murray Boltinoff | |
| 14 | Super Hero Christmas Cards | activity | 2 | script: Paul Levitz; pencils: Wayne Boring, Neal Adams, Irv Novick, Mike Sekowsky; inks: Wayne Boring, Neal Adams, Dick Giordano, Bernard Sachs; letters: Milt Snapinn | Superman; Batman; Robin; Green Arrow (head shot only); Wonder Woman (head shot only); The Flash (head shot only); Captain Marvel |
| 16 | Santa's Guessing Game | activity | 1 | | Santa Claus |
| 17 | The Super-Villains Speak Out on Christmas | cartoon | 1 | script: Paul Levitz; pencils: Curt Swan, C. C. Beck, Murphy Anderson, John Forte; inks: Murphy Anderson, John Forte | Toyman; Penguin; Joker; Mr. Mind; Lex Luthor; Captain Cold; Bizarro |