| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Jim Cheung; inks: Jim Cheung; colors: Tomeu Morey | The Joker; Professor Zoom [Reverse Flash; Eobard Thawne]; Bane; Black Manta; Thaal Sinestro; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; The Batman Who Laughs; The Cheetah [Barbara Ann Minerva]; Brainiac; Gorilla Grodd |
| 1 | The Amateur | comic story | 8 | script: Gabriel Hardman, Corinna Bechko; pencils: Gabriel Hardman; inks: Gabriel Hardman; colors: Matt Hollingsworth; letters: Steve Wands | The Joker; Steve; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 2 | Slaybells Ring | comic story | 8 | script: Kenny Porter; pencils: Ramon Villalobos; inks: Ramon Villalobos; colors: Tamra Bonvillain; letters: Tom Napolitano | Toyman [Winslow Schott]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Lois Lane |
| 3 | Bright and Terrible | comic story | 8 | script: Phillip Kennedy Johnson; pencils: Sumit Kumar; inks: Sumit Kumar; colors: Romulo Fajardo Jr.; letters: Clayton Cowles | Thaal Sinestro; Lex Luthor |
| 4 | Auld Lang Ivy | comic story | 6 | script: Jim Krieg; pencils: Aneke; inks: Aneke; colors: Hi-Fi; letters: Wes Abbott | Poison Ivy [Pamela Isley]; Orca [Grace Balin]; The Eraser; Ten-Eyed Man ["Ten-Eye" Reardon]; Cluemaster [Arthur Brown]; Zebra Man; Polka-Dot Man; Scorpiana; Penguin [Oswald Cobblepot]; The Abacus [Herman Scrivener] (death) |
| 5 | Winter's Root | comic story | 8 | script: Dan Watters; pencils: Alessandro Vitti; inks: Alessandro Vitti; colors: Adriano Lucas; letters: Gabriela Downie | Ares; Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira]; Morea (flashback) |
| 6 | A Coal in My Stocking | comic story | 8 | script: Ram V; pencils: Anthony Spay; inks: Jon Sibal; colors: Jeromy Cox; letters: ALW's Troy Peteri | Black Adam; Antalya; Ni'Klaus of Myra |
| 7 | New Year, New You | comic story | 10 | script: Christos Gage; pencils: Karl Mostert; inks: Karl Mostert; colors: Luis Guerrero; letters: Travis Lanham | Calendar Man [Julian Day]; Killer Croc [Waylon Jones]; Doctor Teisch; Amygdala; Firefly; Batman [Bruce Wayne] |
| 8 | Father Christmas | comic story | 8 | script: Dave Wielgosz; pencils: Cian Tormey; inks: Cian Tormey; colors: Dave McCaig; letters: AndWorld Design; editing: Alex Antone | Chronos [David Clinton]; Cliff Clinton (father of Chronos); Audrey Clinton (mother of Chronos); Gabriel Walker |
| 9 | ...And a Prankster New Year! | comic story | 8 | script: Kurt Busiek; pencils: Dale Eaglesham; inks: Dale Eaglesham; colors: Mike Atiyeh; letters: Todd Klein | The Prankster [Oswald Loomis]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Maria (Prankster assistant); Jayla (Prankster assistant); Petra (Prankster assistant); Martha (Prankster assistant); Green Lantern [John Stewart] (flashback); The Flash [Barry Allen] (flashback); Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira] (flashb |
| 10 | Little Christmas Tree | comic story | 8 | script: Vita Ayala; pencils: Elena Casagrande; inks: Elena Casagrande; colors: Jordie Bellaire; letters: Dave Sharpe | Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Renee Montoya; Kate Kane (flashback) |