| 0 | Who Is the Phantom Stranger? | cover | 1 | pencils: Carmine Infantino; inks: Sy Barry; letters: Ira Schnapp | The Phantom Stranger First |
| 1 | Superman Says: "It's Smart to Check-- And Doublecheck!" | public service announcement | 1 | script: Jack Schiff; pencils: Win Mortimer; inks: Win Mortimer; letters: Ira Schnapp | Clark Kent, Superman |
| 2 | The Haunters from Beyond! | comic story | 8 | script: Manly Wade Wellman; pencils: Carmine Infantino; inks: Sy Barry; letters: Gaspar Saladino | The Phantom Stranger First |
| 5 | Editorial Advisory Board | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 6 | When Dead Men Walk! | comic story | 6 | script: John Broome, Gardner Fox; pencils: Carmine Infantino; inks: Sy Barry, Joe Giella; letters: Gaspar Saladino | The Phantom Stranger First |
| 7 | Message to Parents - What to Do if Polio Comes Your Way | public service announcement | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 9 | Goblin in the Bottle | comic story | 5.67 | script: John Broome; pencils: Murphy Anderson; inks: Murphy Anderson; letters: Ira Schnapp | Moira Varner; Don Holborn; Susan Parks; Latham |
| 11 | Whistle Magic | comic story | 1 | script: Mort Drucker; pencils: Mort Drucker; inks: Mort Drucker | |
| 12 | Fate Takes a Hand | text article | 2 | script: Jack Miller; pencils: Raymond Perry; inks: Raymond Perry | |
| 13 | The House of Strange Secrets! | comic story | 6 | script: John Broome; pencils: Carmine Infantino; inks: Joe Giella; letters: Gaspar Saladino | The Phantom Stranger First |
| 14 | Two More Thrilling Magazines for Mystery Fans! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Gil Kane, Amilcar Ruben Moreira; inks: Murphy Anderson, Amilcar Ruben Moreira; letters: Ira Schnapp | |