| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Alex Toth; inks: Alex Toth; colors: Mark Chiarello | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian] |
| 1 | Table of Contents | table of contents | 2 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian] |
| 2 | Foreword | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 2 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko | Woozy Winks |
| 3 | Introduction | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 3 | script: Peter L. Myer; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian] |
| 4 | Cover - Police Comics #1 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin | The Firebrand; Plastic Man; The Human Bomb; Phantom Lady; The Mouthpiece |
| 5 | The Origin of Plastic Man | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian] (first appearance; origin); VILLAINS: Skizzle Shanks; Skizzle Shank's mob |
| 6 | Cover - Police Comics #2 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin | Firebrand; Plastic Man; #711; The Mouthpiece; The Human Bomb |
| 7 | Duelling the Dope Smugglers | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Captain Murphy [also known as Captain Murphey] (first appearance); VILLAINS: Dopey Joe; Cookie; Senator A.J. Simms |
| 8 | Cover - Police Comics #3 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Will Eisner; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin | Firebrand; Plastic Man; The Human Bomb; #711; The Mouthpiece |
| 9 | The Pinball Racket | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Captain Murphy [also known as Captain Murphey]; VILLAIN: Baldy Bushwack |
| 10 | Cover - Police Comics #4 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin | Firebrand; Plastic Man; #711; Phantom Lady; The Human Bomb; Eagle Evans |
| 11 | Crime School for Delinquent Girls | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; VILLAINS: Madam Brawn (first appearance); Lefty Goon |
| 12 | Cover - Police Comics #5 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Firebrand; #711; The Human Bomb; Chic Carter |
| 13 | The Return of Madam Brawn | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Captain Murphy [also known as Captain Murphey]; VILLAIN: Madam Brawn (dies) |
| 14 | Cover - Police Comics #6 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Firebrand; Phantom Lady; The Human Bomb; #711; The Mouthpiece |
| 15 | Case of the Disembodied Hands | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Ed Cronin | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; VILLAIN: Chubby Rankin |
| 16 | Cover - Police Comics #7 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Firebrand; The Human Bomb; Phantom Lady; #711; Chic Carter |
| 17 | The United Crooks of America | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Captain Murphy [also known as Captain Murphey]; VILLAINS: United Crooks of America [Slug; Slim; Ape Ellson; Trigger Jones] |
| 18 | Cover - Police Comics #8 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Firebrand; #711; The Human Bomb; Phantom Lady; The Mouthpiece |
| 19 | The Sinister Eight Ball | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; VILLAIN: Prof. McSneer (first appearance) |
| 20 | Cover - Police Comics #9 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; #711; The Human Bomb; Manhunter; Firebrand; Chic Carter |
| 21 | Satan's Son Sells Out to the Japs | comic story | 9 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Officer Plotz; VILLAINS: Hairy Arms [also as Mrs. Reknits] (first appearance); Slug (dies); Wooley (dies); Arson Carson |
| 22 | Cover - Police Comics #10 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Firebrand; #711; Phantom Lady; Manhunter; The Human Bomb |
| 23 | The Cyclop Caper | comic story | 9 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Omar McGootch (first appearance); VILLAINS: Zack; Cyclop (first appearance) |
| 24 | Cover - Police Comics #11 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit; Manhunter; #711; Chic Carter; The Human Bomb |
| 25 | The Brain of Cyrus Smythe | comic story | 9 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Tad Wilkins (first appearance; dies); Mr. Wilkins (dies); Mrs. Wilkins (dies); Valda; Shirley; Father Time (cameo); VILLAIN: Cyrus Smythe (first appearance) |
| 26 | Cover - Police Comics #12 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit; #711; Manhunter; The Human Bomb; Chic Carter |
| 27 | The Sinister Swami | comic story | 9 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Rita Johns (first appearance); Captain Murphey [also known as Captain Murphy]; VILLAINS: Looie; Swami; Skipper O'Toole |
| 28 | Cover - Police Comics #13 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Reed Crandall; inks: Reed Crandall; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit; Manhunter; Chic Carter; #711; The Human Bomb |
| 29 | Presenting the Man Who Can't Be Harmed | comic story | 9 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks (first appearance; origin); Zambi ze Soothzayer (first appearance); Homer Twitchel (first appearance); Captain Murphey [also known as Captain Murphy]; VILLAIN: Mr. Mire (first appearance) |
| 30 | Cover - Police Comics #14 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit; Manhunter; #711; Chic Carter; The Human Bomb |
| 31 | Oh, Plastic Man! | comic story | 13 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Captain Murphey [also known as Captain Murphy]; Officer Mike |
| 32 | Cover - Police Comics #15 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit |
| 33 | The Weather Weapon | comic story | 13 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Dr. Egrett (first appearance; dies); Boreas (first appearance); VILLAIN: Ratty McGoon (first appearance); Don Snitzel (first appearance) |
| 34 | Cover - Police Comics #16 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; The Spirit; Ebony |
| 35 | The Revenge of Chief Great Warrior | comic story | 13 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Blackfoot Indians; Will Hawes (first appearance); Mayor Crowley; Police Commissioner Kane; Captain Murphy [also known as Captain Murphey]; Officer Danny; VILLAIN: Chief Great Warrior (first appearance) |
| 36 | Cover - Police Comics #17 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit |
| 37 | Murder in Maniac Mansion | comic story | 13 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Director Steinmetz (dies); Gar Crochett; Dave (dies); Mrs. Dave; VILLAIN: Stanley Vane |
| 38 | Cover - Police Comics #18 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit |
| 39 | The Drafting of Plastic Man | comic story | 13 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Captain Murphey [also known as Captain Murphy]; Professor Van Dyke (first appearance; dies); VILLAIN: Pogo Flinch (first appearance) |
| 40 | Cover - Police Comics #19 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit; Ebony |
| 41 | The Forest of Fear | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian; also as Mr. Gridley] (origin retold); Woozy Winks; Mr. Hadley (first appearance); Mr. Procter (dies); Mr. Ratter (first appearance); Sparkie (first appearance; dies); Tony |
| 42 | Cover - Police Comics #20 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; The Spirit |
| 43 | Woozy Winks Detective Agency | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: Jack Cole; editing: John Beardsley | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Jack Cole; VILLAINS: Abba (first appearance); Dabba (first appearance) |
| 44 | Biographies | text article | 1 | script: Peter L. Myer, Adam Philips | |
| 45 | Backcover | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Gill Fox; inks: Gill Fox; colors: Tom Ziuko; editing: Ed Cronin, Gill Fox | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian] |