| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 1 | Table of Contents | table of contents | 2 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian] |
| 2 | Foreword | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 2 | script: Michael T. Gilbert; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison | Woozy Winks |
| 3 | Cover - Plastic Man #5 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 4 | They Called Him Weapons | comic story | 12 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; VILLAINS: Weapons (first appearance; dies); Jimalong (first appearance); Hoopsnake (first appearance) |
| 5 | The Mysterious Being Called Hate | comic story | 12 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Alex Kotzky; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; VILLAINS: Hate (first appearance); Mr. Giglamp (first appearance; dies); Mr. Rickens (first appearance) |
| 6 | Robin Hood Returns | comic story | 8 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Bart Tumey; inks: Bart Tumey; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Woozy Winks; VILLAIN: Robin Hood [Corkscrew Cal] (first appearance) |
| 7 | Snig River | text story | 2 | script: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Lute Beezer (first appearance); Attorney Gaycat (first appearance); Haggai Beezer (first appearance); Hooks Hoogan (first appearance) |
| 8 | The Evil Money of Moneybags | comic story | 14 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Spranger; inks: Jack Spranger; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Montmorency (first appearance); Joe; VILLAIN: Moneybags [Aloysius P. Japers] (first appearance); Dokey (first appearance) |
| 9 | Cover - Police Comics #59 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 10 | The Menace of Mr. Happiness | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: André LeBlanc; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; VILLAIN: Mr. Happiness [Bender Bellows] (first appearance) |
| 11 | Cover - Police Comics #60 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Professor Spindrift |
| 12 | The Man Who Built Himself a Body | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: André LeBlanc; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; VILLAINS: Professor Spindrift (first appearance); Mr Garoogy (first appearance) |
| 13 | Cover - Police Comics #61 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 14 | A Bundle of Trouble | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: André LeBlanc; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; VILLAINS: Gasper Geetus (first appearance); Big-Nose Grogan (first appearance); Harry Hood (first appearance); Fizz-Fizz (first appearance); Loogy (first appearance); Goo-Goo Gates (first appearance); Lawbook Lawson (first appearance) |
| 15 | Cover - Plastic Man #6 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 16 | The Moon Wizard | comic story | 12 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; The Moon Wizard [Professor Breen] (first appearance); VILLAINS: Scientific Sherman (first appearance); Mabel the Moocher (first appearance) |
| 17 | The Crimes of Mother Goose | comic story | 11 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian; also as Old King Cole]; Woozy Winks [also as Humpty Dumpty]; Mr. Frosby (first appearance); VILLAIN: Mother Goose ["First Reader" McGool; also as Little Jack Horner; also as Little Miss Muffet] (first appearance) |
| 18 | The Zwili Cat | comic story | 8 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Alex Kotzky; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Woozy Winks; VILLAINS: Farthingale (first appearance); Dimbo the Pig Sticker (first appearance; dies) |
| 19 | Starett Goes Straight | text story | 2 | script: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Warden Peters; Mr. Starrett (first appearance); VILLAINS: Snout Morfy (first appearance); Gassy (first appearance) |
| 20 | The Grasshopper | comic story | 14 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Alex Kotzky; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner; Professor Chase (first appearance); VILLAIN: The Grasshopper [Baron De Clout] (first appearance) |
| 21 | Cover - Police Comics #62 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 22 | The Cupid's Bow Murder | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Miss Leda Van Doom (first appearance); Hamlet Upgrade (first appearance; dies); Mr Humdrum (first appearance); Chief Branner; Mr. Wimple (first appearance); Mr. Fowlplay (first appearance); VILLAINS: Mobsy Marrowby (first appearance); The Butler |
| 23 | Cover - Police Comics #63 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Chief Branner |
| 24 | The Crab | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Mr. Darple (first appearance); VILLAIN: the Crab [Bunk Norton] (first appearance; dies); Lefty (dies); Rick |
| 25 | Cover - Police Comics #64 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 26 | Bull's-Eye on Crime | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; VILLAINS: Taffy Welch (first appearance); Nobby Norton (first appearance); Cherry (first appearance); Gumdrop (first appearance); J.J. Rufanuf (first appearance); Felix |
| 27 | Cover - Police Comics #65 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |
| 28 | The Apartment of Dr. Phobia | comic story | 15 | script: Jack Cole; pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; letters: Jack Cole; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks; Daisy (first appearance); George (first appearance); Chief Branner; VILLAINS: Dr. Phobia (first appearance); Sloshoff (first appearance); Broxommen (first appearance) |
| 29 | Biographies | text article | 1 | script: Peter L. Myer, Adam Philips | |
| 30 | Backcover | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Jack Cole; inks: Jack Cole; colors: Jamison; editing: George Brenner | Plastic Man [Eel O'Brian]; Woozy Winks |