| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira; colors: Allen Passalaqua | |
| 1 | - | blank page(s) | 2 | | |
| 2 | Showcase Presents Tales of the Unexpected | credits, title page | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 3 | Table of Contents | table of contents | 5 | letters: typeset | |
| 4 | Tales of the Unexpected #1 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 5 | The "Out-of-the-World Club" | comic story | 6 | pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 6 | The Dream Lamp | comic story | 6 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 7 | The Secret of Cell Sixteen | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Miller; pencils: Howard Purcell; inks: Charles Paris | |
| 8 | The Cartoon That Came to Life | comic story | 6 | script: Otto Binder; pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 9 | Tales of the Unexpected #2 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 10 | The Magic Hats of M'sieu La Farge | comic story | 6 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 11 | The Fastest Man Alive | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Draut; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 12 | The Record of Doom | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 13 | The Gorilla Who Saved the World | comic story | 6 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 14 | Tales of the Unexpected #3 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 15 | The Highway to Tomorrow | comic story | 6 | pencils: Howard Purcell; inks: Howard Purcell | |
| 16 | The Man Nobody Could See! | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Marvin Stein | |
| 17 | I Lost My Past | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Drucker; inks: Mort Drucker | |
| 18 | The Man with 100 Wigs | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Miller; pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 19 | Tales of the Unexpected #4 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 20 | Seven Steps to the Unknown | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 21 | The Day I Broke All Records | comic story | 6 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 22 | The Flowers of Sorcery | comic story | 6 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 23 | The House Where Dreams Came True | comic story | 6 | pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 24 | Tales of the Unexpected #5 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 25 | The Man Who Laughed at Locks | comic story | 6 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 26 | I Was Bewitched for a Day | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 27 | The Living Paintings | comic story | 6 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 28 | The Second Life of Geoffrey Hawkes | comic story | 6 | script: Jack Miller; pencils: John Prentice; inks: John Prentice | |
| 29 | Tales of the Unexpected #6 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 30 | The Telecast from the Future | comic story | 6 | pencils: George Papp; inks: George Papp | |
| 31 | Dial M for Magic | comic story | 5 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 32 | The Forbidden Flowers | comic story | 6 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 33 | The Girl in the Bottle | comic story | 6 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 34 | Tales of the Unexpected #7 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 35 | The Pen That Never Lied! | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 36 | Beware, I Can Read Your Mind | comic story | 6 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 37 | The Forbidden Wish | comic story | 4 | pencils: George Roussos; inks: George Roussos | |
| 38 | The Face in the Clock | comic story | 6 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 39 | Tales of the Unexpected #8 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 40 | The Man Who Stole a Genie | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 41 | The Secret of the Elephant's Tusk | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 42 | The Four Seeds of Destiny! | comic story | 6 | pencils: George Roussos; inks: George Roussos | |
| 43 | The Camera That Could Rob | comic story | 6 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 44 | Tales of the Unexpected #9 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 45 | The Amazing Cube! | comic story | 6 | script: George Kashdan; pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 46 | The Carbon Copy Man | comic story | 6 | pencils: George Papp; inks: George Papp | |
| 47 | The Day Nobody Died | comic story | 6 | pencils: George Roussos; inks: George Roussos | |
| 48 | The Man Who Ate Fire | comic story | 6 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 49 | Tales of the Unexpected #10 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 50 | The Strangest Show on Earth | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jim Mooney; inks: Jim Mooney | |
| 51 | The Phantom Mariner | comic story | 6 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 52 | The Duplicate Man | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 53 | I Was Slave to the Wizard's Lamp | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 54 | Tales of the Unexpected #11 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 55 | Who Am I? | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 56 | I Was a Man From the Future | comic story | 6 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 57 | The Ghost of Hollywood | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 58 | The Man Who Hated Green | comic story | 6 | pencils: Leonard Starr; inks: Leonard Starr | |
| 59 | Tales of the Unexpected #12 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 60 | The Four Threads of Doom | comic story | 6 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 61 | The Witch's Statues | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 62 | The All-Seeing Eye | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 63 | The Indestructible Man | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 64 | Tales of the Unexpected #13 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 65 | Weapons of Destiny | comic story | 6 | script: Otto Binder; pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 66 | The Thing from the Skies | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 67 | Second Warning! | comic story | 4 | pencils: George Papp; inks: George Papp | |
| 68 | I Was a Prisoner of the Supernatural | comic story | 6 | script: Ed Herron; pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 69 | The Face Behind the Mask | comic story | 6 | script: Ed Herron; pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 70 | Tales of the Unexpected #14 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 71 | The Forbidden Game | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 72 | Cry, Clown, Cry | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 73 | The Man Who Owned King Arthur's Sword | comic story | 6 | pencils: George Papp; inks: George Papp | |
| 74 | The Green Gorilla | comic story | 6 | pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 75 | Tales of the Unexpected #15 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 76 | Three Wishes to Doom | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 77 | The Sinister Cannon | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 78 | The Rainbow Man | comic story | 6 | pencils: George Roussos; inks: George Roussos | |
| 79 | The City of Three Dooms | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 80 | Tales of the Unexpected #16 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 81 | The Magic Hammer | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 82 | I Was a Spy for Them | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 83 | The Exile from Earth | comic story | 6 | script: Dave Wood; pencils: Sheldon Moldoff; inks: Sheldon Moldoff | |
| 84 | The Interplantary Line-Up | comic story | 6 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 85 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 86 | Tales of the Unexpected #17 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ruben Moreira, Jack Adler; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 87 | Who Is Mr. Ashtar? | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 88 | Beware the Thinking Cap | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 89 | The Bullet Man | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 90 | The Impossible Voyage | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jim Mooney; inks: Jim Mooney | |
| 91 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 92 | Tales of the Unexpected #18 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 93 | The Man Without a World | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jim Mooney; inks: Jim Mooney | |
| 94 | The Riddle of the Glass Bubble | comic story | 6 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | |
| 95 | The Amazing Swap Shop | comic story | 6 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 96 | The Man Who Collected Planets | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Jack Kirby | |
| 97 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 98 | Tales of the Unexpected #19 | comic story | 1 | pencils: Bob Brown; inks: Bob Brown | |
| 99 | The Man From Two Worlds | comic story | 6 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 100 | D-Day on Planet Vulcan | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jim Mooney; inks: Jim Mooney | |
| 101 | The Human Lie Detector | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 102 | The Menace of the Fireball | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bob Brown; inks: Bob Brown | |
| 103 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 104 | Tales of the Unexpected #20 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 105 | The Earth Gladiator | comic story | 6 | pencils: Nick Cardy; inks: Nick Cardy | |
| 106 | The Remarkable Mr. Multiplier | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bill Ely; inks: Bill Ely | |
| 107 | I Was Marooned on Planet Earth | comic story | 6 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Bernard Baily | |
| 108 | You Stole Our Planet | comic story | 6 | pencils: Ruben Moreira; inks: Ruben Moreira | |
| 109 | The Graphic Novels Section of DCCOMICS.com | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 110 | Tales of the Unexpected Volume 1 | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |