| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Alex Ross; inks: Alex Ross; colors: Alex Ross | Superman; Batman |
| 1 | Superman / Batman: The Greatest Stories Ever Told | illustration | 1 | pencils: Alex Ross; inks: Alex Ross; colors: Alex Ross | Superman; Batman |
| 2 | - | credits, title page | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 3 | Contents | table of contents | 2 | letters: typeset | |
| 4 | The Mightiest Team in the World! | comic story | 12 | script: Edmond Hamilton; pencils: Curt Swan; inks: John Fischetti, Stan Kaye | Superman [Clark Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; John Smilter; Lois Lane; Gell; Commissioner James Gordon |
| 5 | Superman and Batman's Greatest Foes! | comic story | 12 | script: Edmond Hamilton; pencils: Dick Sprang; inks: Stan Kaye | Superman [Clark Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Lex Luthor; Joker; Lois Lane; Perry White; Mechano-Men |
| 6 | The Composite Superman! | comic story | 18 | script: Edmond Hamilton; pencils: Curt Swan; inks: George Klein, Sheldon Moldoff | Composite Superman [Joe Meach]; Legion of Super-heroes [Sun Boy; Brainiac 5; Mon-El; Saturn Girl]; Commissioner James Gordon; Lois Lane; Superman [Clark Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Jimmy Olsen |
| 7 | The Cape and Cowl Crooks! | comic story | 18 | script: Edmond Hamilton; pencils: Curt Swan; inks: George Klein | Superman [Clark Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Joker; Penguin; Toyman; Prankster; Anti-Superman; Anti-Batman; Commissioner James Gordon; Perry White; Chief O'Hara |
| 8 | The Superman-Batman Split! | comic story | 18 | script: Cary Bates; pencils: Neal Adams; inks: Neal Adams, Dick Giordano | Superman [Clark Kent]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Robin [Dick Grayson]; Supergirl [Kara Zor-El]; Batgirl [Barbara Gordon]; James Gordon; Jimmy Olsen; Ronald Jason; Desmond Jason |
| 9 | A Matter of Light and Death! | comic story | 24 | script: Len Wein; pencils: Dick Dillin; inks: Joe Giella | Superman; Batman; Dr. Light; Zatanna (cameo); Nicholas Slye |
| 10 | One Night in Gotham City... | comic story | 22 | script: John Byrne; pencils: John Byrne; inks: Dick Giordano; colors: Tom Ziuko; letters: John Costanza | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Henry Jarrell; Magpie [Margaret Pye]; Bull Carter |
| 11 | A Better World | comic story | 22 | script: Karl Kesel; pencils: Peter Doherty; inks: Robert Campanella; colors: Alex Sinclair; letters: Clem Robins | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El; also as Gang Buster (cameo, flashback)]; Alfred Pennyworth; Jonathan Kent; Martha Kent; Pete Ross (cameo); Doc Waters; Sarah Muller; Joker (cameo) |
| 12 | When Clark Met Bruce | comic story | 2 | script: Jeph Loeb; pencils: Tim Sale; inks: Tim Sale; colors: Mark Chiarello; letters: Comicraft | Pete Ross; Clark Kent; Bruce Wayne; Alfred Pennyworth |
| 13 | Stop Me If You've Heard This One... | comic story | 38 | script: Joe Kelly; pencils: Ed McGuinness, Ryan Ottley, Sean Murphy, Carlo Barberi; inks: Dexter Vines, Cliff Rathburn, Sean Murphy, Don Hillsman II, Bob Petrecca, Andy Owens; colors: Guy Major; letters: Rob Leigh | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Lois Lane; Alfred Pennyworth; Deathstroke [Slade Wilson]; Crime Syndicate [Owlman; Superwoman; Ultraman]; Mr. Mxyzptlk |
| 14 | The World's Finest Duo Teams Up! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Alex Ross; inks: Alex Ross; colors: Alex Ross | |