| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Tim Sale; inks: Tim Sale; colors: Dave Stewart | John Winchester; Dean Winchester; Sam Winchester |
| 1 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 2 | Supernatural | credits, title page | 1 | pencils: J. G. Jones; inks: J. G. Jones; colors: Alex Sinclair | John Winchester |
| 3 | - | credits, title page | 2 | letters: typeset | |
| 4 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Tim Bradstreet; inks: Tim Bradstreet; colors: Tim Bradstreet | Mary Winchester |
| 5 | Chapter One | comic story | 20 | script: Peter Johnson; pencils: Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Matthew Dow Smith; colors: JD Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | John Winchester; Mary Winchester (death); Sam Winchester; Dean Winchester; Julie (death); Randy; Missouri Mosley |
| 6 | Chapter Two | comic story | 22 | script: Peter Johnson; pencils: Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Matthew Dow Smith; colors: JD Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | John Winchester; Dean Winchester; Sam Winchester; Fletcher Gable; Uncle Jacob (death); H (a hunter) |
| 7 | Chapter Three | comic story | 22 | script: Peter Johnson; pencils: Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Matthew Dow Smith; colors: JD Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | Dean Winchester; Sam Winchester; John Winchester; H (a hunter); Ratboy Jim Harvelle; Ellen Harvelle; Ichi (death); Springheel Jack; Shapeshifter "Ichi" (death); Bill; Pam |
| 8 | - | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Dustin Nguyen; inks: Dustin Nguyen; colors: Dustin Nguyen | John Winchester |
| 9 | Chapter Four | comic story | 22 | script: Peter Johnson; pencils: Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Matthew Dow Smith; colors: JD Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | |
| 10 | Chapter Five | comic story | 23 | script: Peter Johnson; pencils: Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Matthew Dow Smith; colors: JD Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | |
| 11 | Chapter Six | comic story | 21 | script: Peter Johnson; pencils: Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Matthew Dow Smith; colors: JD Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | |
| 12 | - | credits, title page | 1 | pencils: Tony Harris; inks: Tony Harris; colors: Tony Harris | John Winchester |
| 13 | Speak No Evil | comic story | 5 | script: Geoff Johns; pencils: Phil Hester; inks: Phil Hester; colors: J. D. Mettler; letters: Greg Thompson | Sam Winchester; Dean Winchester; John Winchester |
| 14 | Gallery | illustration | 2 | pencils: Tim Sale, Matthew Dow Smith; inks: Tim Sale, Matthew Dow Smith; colors: Dave Stewart, JD Mettler | |
| 15 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 16 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 17 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Ryan Sook; inks: Ryan Sook; colors: Ryan Sook | John Winchester |