| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Andy Kubert; inks: Andy Kubert; colors: Brad Anderson | The Flash [Barry Allen]; Green Lantern [Jessica Cruz]; Wonder Woman [Diana of Themyscira]; Batwoman [Kate Kane]; Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Supergirl [Kara Zor-El]; Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Superman [Clark Kent] (headshot only); Green Lantern [Simon Baz] (headshot only) |
| 1 | 'Twas the Riot Before Christmas | comic story | 12 | script: Scott Lobdell; pencils: Brett Booth; inks: Norm Rapmund; colors: Hi-Fi; letters: Saida Temofonte; editing: Jamie S. Rich, Brittany Holzherr | The Flash [Barry Allen]; Girder [Tony Woodward]; Mirror Master [Sam Scudder]; Gorilla Grodd; Magenta [Frances Kane]; King Shark; Double Down [Jeremy Tell]; Pied Piper [Hartley Rathaway]; Heat Wave [Mick Rory]; Captain Cold [Leonard Snart]; Trickster [Axel Walker]; unnamed Iron Height guards; Mrs. Mu |
| 2 | Metropolis Mailbag | comic story | 22 | script: Dan Jurgens; pencils: Jackson Guice; inks: Jackson Guice; colors: Glenn Whitmore; letters: John Costanza | Superman [Clark Kent; Kal-El]; Willie Simpkins; Lois Lane; Professor Emil Hamilton; Alfred Pennyworth (cameo); Bruce Wayne [Batman] (cameo); Pete Ross (cameo); Lana Lang (cameo, engagement announced); Agnes Schommer; Ellie Schommer; Terry Baldwin Jr.; Mrs. Baldwin; Gloria |
| 3 | All I Want For Christmas... | comic story | 10 | script: Joe Kelly; pencils: Alé Garza; inks: Alé Garza, Tim Townsend; colors: J. J. Kirby; letters: Travis Lanham; editing: Eddie Berganza, Jeanine Schaefer | Supergirl [Kara Zor-El]; Clark Kent [Superman; Kal-El]; Alfred Pennyworth |
| 4 | Good Boy | comic story | 8 | script: Tom King; pencils: David Finch; inks: David Finch; colors: Gabe Eltaeb; letters: Deron Bennett | Batman [Bruce Wayne]; Commissioner James Gordon]; Alfred Pennyworth; Ace |
| 5 | Light in the Dark | comic story | 10 | script: K. Perkins; pencils: Paolo Pantalena; inks: Paolo Pantalena; colors: Arif Prianto; letters: Josh Reed; editing: Eddie Berganza | Batwoman [Kate Kane]; Tributary; Kit [Zenith] |
| 6 | Killin' Time | comic story | 9 | script: Amanda Conner, Jimmy Palmiotti; pencils: Darwyn Cooke; inks: Darwyn Cooke; colors: Dave Stewart; letters: John J. Hill | Harley Quinn [Harleen Quinzel]; Bernie (a beaver); Big Tony; Harold Tyme; Lillian Tyme; Mr. Tyme; Mrs. Tyme; Queenie |
| 7 | The Epiphany | comic story | 10 | script: Steve Orlando, Vita Ayala; pencils: V Ken Marion; inks: Mick Gray; colors: Tony Aviña; letters: Josh Reed; editing: Andrew Marino | Green Lantern [Simon Baz]; Green Lantern [Jessica Cruz]; Sarah Cruz; the Reckx; Red Lantern [Atrocitus] (flashback); Red Lantern [Zilius Zox] (flashback); Red Lantern [Skallox] (flashback); The Flash [Barry Allen] (flashback) |