| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig | The Old Witch (inset); The Vault-Keeper (inset); The Crypt-Keeper (inset) |
| 1 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | A Strange Undertaking... | comic story | 8 | script: Ray Bradbury, Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Graham Ingels; inks: Graham Ingels; letters: Jim Wroten | The Old Witch (host); Ezra Deepley (undertaker, death); Clem Bookin (cemetery caretaker); Mrs. Bridgeman (voice only); John Bridgeman (Mrs. Bridgeman's husband, dentist, cameo, also in flashback, death); Fredrick Dunhill (town Mayor, cameo, also in flashback, death); Horace Streetwall (banker, cameo |
| 3 | So They Finally Pinned You Down! | comic story | 7 | script: Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Wally Wood; inks: Wally Wood; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (host); three unnamed girls (all die); Dr. Alex Farnsworth (mention only); girl vampire (villain); a drifter (villain, male vampire, death) |
| 4 | Marsh Sand | text story | 1 | script: Al Feldstein | Paul Murdock (death); Richard Murdock (villain, Paul's heir) |
| 5 | - | letters page | 1 | script: Al Feldstein | The Old Witch |
| 6 | A Grave Gag!! | comic story | 6 | script: Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Jack Kamen; inks: Jack Kamen; letters: Jim Wroten | The Old Witch (host); Samuel Westlake (Hiram's brotherdeath); Hiram Westlake (death); Robert Westlake (Hiram's brother); Ezra Westlake (Hiram's brother); Granny; unnamed minister; Lisa Westlake (Robert's wife, death); Jonah Westlake (a jokester, Hiram's brother, death) |
| 7 | Cheese, That's Horrible! | comic story | 7 | script: Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Jack Davis; inks: Jack Davis; letters: Jim Wroten | The Crypt-Keeper (host); Hendrick Villhem (cheese-maker, death); Prince's butler; Bradbury Prince (villain, cheese factory owner, death) |