| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | Ginger Brown; Leander Wight; John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 1 | - | illustration | 2 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock; Wayne Russet; Ginger Brown; the Chupacabra; Elvis Chestnut; Mi-Chen-Po; Colonel Dachshund; August McKraken; Julia Pastrana; the minister; Thunderbirds |
| 2 | Title page | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock; the Dover Demon |
| 3 | credits | credits, title page | 2 | pencils: Chris Grine; inks: Chris Grine; colors: Chris Grine | Joy |
| 4 | Colonel Dachshund illustration | illustration | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Dave Casey | Colonel Dachshund; Thunderbird |
| 5 | Chapter One: Aftermath | comic story | 22 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Dave Casey; letters: Blambot | Mokele-Mbembe; Wayne Russet; Colonel Dachshund; Mothman; fairies; Joy; Thunderbirds; Blue Men of the Minch; Jackalopes; Autumn Song; Graham; Dupond; Rolf; Perry; Hope; the Rabbi |
| 6 | Interlude One: First Contact | comic story | 3 | script: Alex Grecian; pencils: Dave Casey; inks: Dave Casey; colors: Dave Casey; letters: Blambot | John "Proof" Prufrock; Wayne Russet; the Dover Demon |
| 7 | Interlude Two: Lodged | comic story | 7 | script: Alex Grecian; pencils: Paul Fricke; inks: Paul Fricke; colors: Paul Fricke; letters: Blambot | Leander Wight; Qi; the Dover Demon; Wayne Russet; Elvis Chestnut; Edward; fairy; Mokele-Mbembe |
| 8 | Chapter Two: Blue Fairy | comic story | 22 | script: Alexander Grecian; pencils: Chris Grine; inks: Chris Grine; colors: Chris Grine; letters: Blambot | Joy; the Chupacabra; the Dover Demon; Colonel Dachshund; Aranea; Nellie; Mokele-mbembe |
| 9 | Chapter Three: Who Killed the Dover Demon? | comic story | 22 | script: Alex Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Dave Casey; letters: Blambot | John "Proof" Prufrock; Isabella Bay; Mokele-Mbembe; the Chupacabra; Wayne Russet; Joy; Aranea; Nellie; Ginger Brown; Elvis Chestnut; Leander Wight; the Dover Demon; C.K. Dexter Haven |
| 10 | Faith Is Dead | comic story | 23 | script: Alex Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Dave Casey; letters: Blambot | John "Proof" Prufrock; Elvis Chestnut; Ginger Brown; Mothman; C.K. Dexter Haven; Wayne Russet; Joy; Leander Wight; Isabella Bay; the Chupacabra; Hope; Charity |
| 11 | The Expression of Emotions in Man and Animals | comic story | 24 | script: Alex Grecian; pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo; colors: Dave Casey; letters: Blambot | John "Proof" Prufrock; Wayne Russet; Leander Wight; Ginger Brown; the Chupacabra; Mothman; Elvis Chestnut; Isabella Bay; Gloria Wight |
| 12 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock |
| 13 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Riley Rossmo; inks: Riley Rossmo | John "Proof" Prufrock |