| 0 | The Christmas Spirit | cover | 1 | pencils: Will Eisner; inks: Will Eisner; colors: Will Eisner | The Spirit; Santa Claus |
| 1 | Contents | table of contents | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | Introduction | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 1 | script: Will Eisner | |
| 3 | Christmas Spirit of 1940: Black Henry and Simple Simon | comic story | 7 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Will Eisner; inks: Will Eisner; colors: Joe Kubert; letters: Sam Rosen | Spirit; Ebony White; Ellen Dolan; Commissioner Dolan; Black Henry; Simple Simon |
| 4 | The Christmas Spirit: A Trilogy | comic story | 8 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Will Eisner; inks: Will Eisner; colors: Joe Kubert; letters: Sam Rosen | |
| 5 | The Christmas Spirit of 1945: Horton J. Winklenod | comic story | 7 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Jack Spranger; inks: Will Eisner; letters: Martin deMuth | Horton J. Winklenod; Spirit; Dolan; Soups; Killer Cobra's widow; Buggsy Mandone; Ebony; Ellen |
| 6 | The Christmas Spirit A Fable | comic story | 7 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Jack Spranger; inks: Will Eisner, Bob Palmer; letters: Martin deMuth | Octopus; Kilroy [PS]; Brains |
| 7 | The Christmas Spirit of 1947: Joy | comic story | 7 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Will Eisner; inks: Will Eisner, Jerry Grandenetti; letters: Abe Kanegson | Sammy; P'Gell; Saree (Cameo); Klink (cameo); PS (cameo) |
| 8 | The Christmas Spirit of 1948: Basher Bains | comic story | 7 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Will Eisner; inks: Will Eisner; colors: Jamison; letters: Abe Kanegson | Dolan; Ellen; Spirit; Basher Bains; Santa Claus; Teench; Franky |
| 9 | The Christmas Spirit [1949] | comic story | 7 | script: Will Eisner; pencils: Will Eisner; inks: Will Eisner, Jerry Grandenetti; letters: Abe Kanegson | PS; Klink; Dolan |