| 0 | Merry Xmas | cover | 1 | pencils: Kevin O'Neill; inks: Kevin O'Neill; colors: Kevin O'Neill | Pinhead, Elliott Spencer |
| 1 | - | table of contents | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | A Christmas Puzzle | comic story | 4 | script: D. G. Chichester; pencils: Dan Lawlis; inks: Christopher Ivy; colors: Steve Buccellato; letters: Steve Dutro | Atkins, Balberith, Hell's Bastard Son First, Staple Face |
| 3 | Child's Play | comic story | 13 | script: Sholly Fisch; pencils: Steve Buccellato; inks: Steve Buccellato; colors: Steve Buccellato; letters: Gaspar | Steven; KM; Dorothy; Melissa |
| 4 | A Christmas Puzzle [Part 2] | comic story | 2 | script: D. G. Chichester; pencils: Dan Lawlis; inks: Christopher Ivy; colors: Steve Buccellato; letters: Steve Dutro | Atkins, Balberith, Hell's Bastard Son First, Staple Face |
| 5 | Sheddim [as on table of contents]; שדים [as on story page] | comic story | 10 | script: Ben Schwartz; pencils: Tim Conrad; inks: Tim Conrad; colors: Tim Conrad; letters: Steve Dutro | Mr. Goldberg (introduction, death); Jacob Goldberg (introduction); Billy (introduction, death) |
| 6 | A Christmas Puzzle [Part 3] | comic story | 2 | script: D. G. Chichester; pencils: Dan Lawlis; inks: Christopher Ivy; colors: Steve Buccellato; letters: Steve Dutro | Atkins, Balberith, Hell's Bastard Son First, Staple Face |
| 7 | Nursery Crime | comic story | 13 | script: Frank Lovece; pencils: Mike Okamoto; inks: Mike Okamoto; colors: Mike Okamoto; letters: Rick Parker | Crow First, Moonface First |
| 8 | A Christmas Puzzle [Part 4] | comic story | 4 | script: D. G. Chichester; pencils: Dan Lawlis; inks: Christopher Ivy; colors: Steve Buccellato; letters: Steve Dutro | Atkins, Balberith, Hell's Bastard Son First, Staple Face |
| 9 | - | credits, title page | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 10 | Back Cover | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |