| 0 | - | cover | 0 | pencils: Joe Maneely; inks: Carl Burgos | |
| 1 | Credits / Contents | table of contents | 3 | letters: typeset | |
| 2 | The History of Atlas Horror/Fantasy: Post-Code 1955-1956 | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 6 | script: Michael J. Vassallo | |
| 3 | [Strange Tales #40] The Man Who Caught a Mermaid? | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Joe Maneely; inks: Joe Maneely | |
| 4 | This Dark Cave | comic story | 5 | pencils: Bill Benulis; inks: Bill Benulis | |
| 5 | The Search | text story | 2 | letters: typeset | Uwaga; Babu; Narodu |
| 6 | A Stranger on Earth | comic story | 5 | pencils: Bill Everett; inks: Bill Everett; letters: Bill Everett | Lok |
| 7 | The Man Who Caught a Mermaid! | comic story | 4 | pencils: John Forte; inks: John Forte | Joe Blair; Jeremy Torgan |
| 8 | The End of Time! | comic story | 4 | pencils: John Forte; inks: John Forte | |
| 9 | No Place to Hide | comic story | 5 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Paul Reinman; inks: Paul Reinman | David Reynolds; Joshua Swift |
| 10 | [Strange Tales #41] Man in the Dark | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Joe Maneely; inks: Carl Burgos | |
| 11 | The Riddle of the Skull | comic story | 5 | pencils: Fred Kida; inks: Fred Kida | |
| 12 | The Search! | text story | 1.67 | letters: typeset | Eric Dunbar; Isolda |
| 13 | The Fishman | comic story | 5 | script: Bill Everett; pencils: Bill Everett; inks: Bill Everett; letters: Bill Everett | Peter Maher; Elsa; Dr. Bondy |
| 14 | The Strange Stick | comic story | 4 | script: Paul S. Newman; pencils: Robert Q. Sale; inks: Robert Q. Sale | |
| 15 | They Won't Believe | comic story | 4 | pencils: Dick Ayers | Curt Calder |
| 16 | Man in the Dark | comic story | 5 | pencils: Joe Orlando; inks: Joe Orlando | Daniel Reed; Amy Reed |
| 17 | [Strange Tales #42] The Faceless One? | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Sol Brodsky; inks: Sol Brodsky | |
| 18 | The Faceless One | comic story | 5 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Bill Everett; inks: Bill Everett; letters: Bill Everett | Jefferson Horner; Lester Greer; Gilbert Horner; Doctor Lawrence |
| 19 | The Collector | text story | 1.67 | letters: typeset | Donald R. Donalds; Mister Kelt |
| 20 | The Man Who Said No! | comic story | 3 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Joe Maneely; inks: Joe Maneely | Robert Chapin; Emil; Burt |
| 21 | Moon-Man! | comic story | 4 | script: Paul S. Newman; pencils: Bernie Krigstein; inks: Bernie Krigstein | |
| 22 | The Vanishing Brain! | comic story | 5 | pencils: Doug Wildey; inks: Doug Wildey | Philip Hayden; Lorna Bond; Hank Cobb |
| 23 | The Man in the Cell! | comic story | 5 | pencils: Bob Powell; inks: Bob Powell | Jim; Madge; Colin Stone; Ila; Torgan |
| 24 | [Strange Tales #43] The Mysterious Machine! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Russ Heath; inks: Russ Heath | |
| 25 | The Man Who Lived Twice! | comic story | 5 | script: Paul S. Newman; pencils: Tony DiPreta; inks: Tony DiPreta | Hal Walters |
| 26 | The Swami | text story | 1.67 | letters: typeset | Rijak Lobar; John McDermott |
| 27 | I Saved Mankind! | comic story | 4 | pencils: John Forte; inks: John Forte | Lester Harmon |
| 28 | Behind the Mask! | comic story | 5 | pencils: Bob Brown; inks: Bob Brown | Joe Fenton; Agnes Fenton; Ogu |
| 29 | The Mysterious Machine! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Larry Woromay; inks: Steve Kirkel | Fred Harper; Louella Harper |
| 30 | The Unbelievable Man! | comic story | 5 | script: Paul S. Newman; pencils: Bob Forgione; inks: Jack Abel | Professor Bryce; Davis; Noah Javis |
| 31 | Strange Tales #44 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Carl Burgos; inks: Carl Burgos | |
| 32 | The Man Who Ran Away! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Bob Forgione; inks: Bob Forgione | Doctor Ron Kennard; Dan Pierce |
| 33 | One World at a Time! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Joe Orlando; inks: Joe Orlando | Fred Cole; Professor Galton; Alice Towne |
| 34 | - | statement of ownership | 0.33 | letters: typeset | |
| 35 | The Stone | text story | 1.34 | letters: typeset | Joe Carter |
| 36 | The Mysterious Borderer | comic story | 3 | pencils: Robert Q. Sale; inks: Robert Q. Sale | Amy Jones; Felix Donald; Gina; Eileen |
| 37 | Look Out Below! | comic story | 4 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Bob Powell; inks: Bob Powell | Robert Thornton; Dean Lanson |
| 38 | Safari in the Sky! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Ed Winiarski; inks: Ed Winiarski | Luther Rousch; Hammond; Pritchard; Aubrey Pearce |
| 39 | Take a Giant Step | comic story | 4 | pencils: Paul Reinman; inks: Paul Reinman | Bobby; Steve |
| 41 | [Strange Tales #45] Land of Vanishing Men! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Bill Everett; inks: Bill Everett | |
| 42 | Land of Vanishing Men | comic story | 4 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Joe Sinnott; inks: Joe Sinnott | Ted Benson; Joe Ausler; Larry Wiley |
| 43 | The Night People | comic story | 4 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Bob Forgione; inks: Jack Abel | Felix Hunter |
| 44 | The Eyes of Mr. Moody! | comic story | 3 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Jack Keller; inks: Jack Keller | Orville Moody |
| 45 | The Strange Exchange! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Ed Winiarski; inks: Ed Winiarski | Anders |
| 46 | The Impersonation | text story | 2 | letters: typeset | Johnny Graham; Milly Borden; Alice Van Sweldt; Henry Van Sweldt; Marlin Van Sweldt |
| 47 | The Man Who Went Back! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Bernie Krigstein; inks: Bernie Krigstein | Jerry Mason |
| 48 | Sorry, Wrong Planet | comic story | 4 | pencils: Bernard Baily; inks: Joe Sinnott | Jeff Miller |
| 49 | [Strange Tales #46] You Must Not Look! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Carl Burgos; inks: Carl Burgos | |
| 50 | The Sands Are Running Out | comic story | 4 | pencils: Joe Sinnott; inks: Joe Sinnott | Hiram Holt; Tom Fleming |
| 51 | The Man from Nowhere | comic story | 4 | pencils: Joe Orlando; inks: Joe Orlando | Joe Axel; Judy Axel |
| 52 | Repeat Performance | comic story | 3 | pencils: John Severin; inks: John Severin | Ted; Alice; Paul Revere |
| 53 | Planet X | text story | 1.67 | letters: typeset | Biff Holsum; Red |
| 54 | The Wild, Wild Wind | comic story | 4 | pencils: Dick Ayers | Fred Vernes; John Lawton |
| 55 | You Must Not Look | comic story | 4 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Paul Reinman; inks: Paul Reinman | Charlie Boswell; Ada Boswell; Frederic Armstrong; Nora Armstrong |
| 56 | The Greatest Experiment | comic story | 4 | pencils: Steve Ditko; inks: Steve Ditko | |
| 57 | Strange Tales #47 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Sol Brodsky; inks: Sol Brodsky | |
| 58 | When Mankind Vanished! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Frank Bolle; inks: Frank Bolle | Gregory Winston |
| 59 | Overflow | comic story | 4 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Tony DiPreta; inks: Tony DiPreta | Byrop |
| 60 | When Sorcerers Meet! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Bob McCarty; inks: Bob McCarty | Chris Garson; Helen |
| 61 | The Trial of Dr. Volton! | comic story | 4 | script: Carl Wessler; pencils: Ed Winiarski; inks: Ed Winiarski | Emil Volton; Eddie; Stephan Purdy |
| 62 | Magic Melody | text story | 2 | letters: typeset | Gus Harris; Mr. Peters |
| 63 | The New Member! | comic story | 3 | pencils: Vic Carrabotta; inks: Vic Carrabotta | Zad Compton |
| 64 | The Hands | comic story | 4 | pencils: Jim McLaughlin; inks: Jim McLaughlin | Olga Forli; Grigor |
| 65 | Strange Tales #48 | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Carl Burgos; inks: Carl Burgos | |
| 66 | The Deserted Lighthouse! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Bob Forgione; inks: Jack Abel | Dumont |
| 67 | The Man Who Stole a Skyscraper | comic story | 4 | pencils: Manny Stallman; inks: Manny Stallman | |
| 68 | The Man in Space! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Bill Walton; inks: Bill Walton | Don Arlen; Jory; Ruth |
| 69 | I've Got to Hide! | comic story | 4 | pencils: Mort Meskin; inks: Mort Meskin | Mitch; Amos Gallop; Marie |
| 70 | Muscle Man | text story | 2 | letters: typeset | Jimmy Binn; Tooloo |
| 71 | Medicine Man! | comic story | 3 | pencils: Ed Winiarski; inks: Ed Winiarski | Harry Tinker |
| 72 | The Last of Mister Grimm | comic story | 4 | pencils: Dick Ayers; inks: Dick Ayers | Henry Grimm |