| 0 | - | cover | 2 | pencils: Dave Wilkins; inks: Dave Wilkins; colors: Dave Wilkins | Doctor Doom, Victor Von Doom, Emma Frost, Iron Patriot, Loki, Norman Osborn, Robert Reynolds, The Sentry |
| 1 | What If... Norman Osborn Won the Siege of Asgard? | comic story | 22 | script: Marc Guggenheim; pencils: Dave Wilkins, Lucio Parrillo; inks: Dave Wilkins, Lucio Parrillo; colors: Dave Wilkins, Lucio Parrillo; letters: Dave Lanphear | Dark Avengers [Iron Patriot [Norman Osborn]; Ares; Sentry [The Void]; Spider-Man [Mac Gargan]; Hawkeye [Bullseye]; Ms. Marvel [Karla Sofen; Moonstone]; Wolverine [Daken]]; X-Men [Cyclops; Emma Frost [White Queen]; Wolverine; X-23; Beast; Magneto; Nightcrawler; Namor, the Sub-Mariner]; Iron Man [Tony |
| 2 | Previously in Fantastic Four #48-50 | recap | 1 | pencils: Jack Kirby; inks: Joe Sinnott | |
| 3 | What If I, the Watcher, Killed Galactus? | comic story | 10 | script: Stan Lee; pencils: Dale Eaglesham; inks: Dale Eaglesham; colors: Laura Martin; letters: Todd Klein | Fantastic Four [Mr. Fantastic; Invisible Girl; Human Torch; The Thing]; Galactus (death); Silver Surfer; Uatu, the Watcher; other Watchers |
| 4 | What If? A Retrospective with Roy Thomas | text article | 3 | script: Roy Thomas | |
| 5 | What Was Your Favorite What If? | text article | 2 | script: various; pencils: various; inks: various; colors: various; letters: typeset | |
| 6 | ... What If Bullseye Had Not Killed Elektra? | comic story | 16 | script: Frank Miller; pencils: Frank Miller; inks: Terry Austin; colors: Glynis Wein; letters: Joe Rosen | Daredevil [Matt Murdock]; Elektra; Watcher; Bullseye; Foggy Nelson; Kingpin; Eric Slaughter; Becky Blake |
| 7 | What If? 200 Cover Gallery | cover reprint (on interior page) | 4 | pencils: various; inks: various; colors: various; letters: typeset | |