| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: George Wilson; inks: George Wilson; colors: George Wilson | |
| 1 | It's Magic! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | script: ? (promo copy); letters: typeset | Mickey Mouse; Donald Duck; Scrooge McDuck; Huey; Louie; Dewey; Goofy; Pluto; Doc; Chip; Dale; Jiminy Cricket |
| 2 | Contents | table of contents | 2 | letters: typeset | |
| 3 | The Lost Colonie | comic story | 9 | pencils: Giovanni Ticci; inks: Giovanni Ticci; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Charley Paine; Governor |
| 4 | The Shadow with Claws | comic story | 15 | script: Leo Dorfman; pencils: Joe Orlando; inks: Angelo Torres; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Strobus (death); Flamma (death) |
| 5 | The Amazing Mr. Home | text story | 3 | pencils: Joe Certa; inks: Joe Certa | Daniel Home |
| 6 | The Night Striker of Paris | comic story | 12 | script: Dick Wood; pencils: Mel Crawford; inks: Mel Crawford; letters: Ben Oda | Inspector Dubois; Madame Gabeau |
| 7 | The High Cost of Dying | comic story | 7 | script: Don Glut; pencils: Dan Spiegle; inks: Dan Spiegle; letters: Bill Spicer | Sam Jombo; David Price (death); Van Sickel (flashback) (zombie) |
| 8 | Iron Man No. 1 | comic story | 13 | pencils: Dick Rockwell; inks: Dick Rockwell; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Iron Man No. 1; George; Mr. Teek; Grace; Sam |
| 9 | The Captive | comic story | 4 | script: Paul S. Newman; pencils: Alex Toth; inks: Alex Toth; letters: Ben Oda | Mr. Gruber; Cynthia; Gladys; Wyatt Earp; Bat Masterson; Billy the Kid; Johnny Ringo; Wild Bill Hickock |
| 10 | The Death Car | comic story | 4 | pencils: Giovanni Ticci; inks: Alberto Giolitti; letters: Ben Oda | Hugo; Archduke Franz Ferninand (death); Dr. Srkis (death); Mr. Hirshfield (death) |
| 11 | The Thing from the Haunted Lagoon | comic story | 10 | script: Don Glut; pencils: Jesse Santos; inks: Jesse Santos; letters: Bill Spicer | Rod Serling (host); Bill Roddy; Dr. Zangerl |
| 12 | The Lost Genius | comic story | 5 | script: Dick Wood; pencils: Joe Orlando; inks: Joe Orlando; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Peter C. Mansfield; Professor Duhamel; Professor Enwright; Tommy; Rendar |
| 13 | The Ghost in the Drifting Tomb | text story | 3 | pencils: Joe Certa; inks: Joe Certa | Hans Engellandt |
| 14 | ("Wanted...Alive!") Doomsday in Dusterville | comic story | 9 | script: Dick Wood; pencils: Joe Certa; inks: Joe Certa; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Big Dobin; Mayor Parker (death); Sheriff; Tod Watson; space vigilante |
| 15 | The Day That Vanished | comic story | 11 | script: Dick Wood; pencils: Reed Crandall; inks: Reed Crandall; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Brian Higgens; Mr. Eastover; Mrs. Canfield; Jack; Mr. Connors; Andy; Bob |
| 16 | Hearts and Flowers | comic story | 8 | script: Don Glut; pencils: Dan Spiegle; inks: Dan Spiegle; letters: Bill Spicer | Dr. Spektor (host); Douglas Murch (death); Brenda Grey; Ida |
| 17 | The Voice in the Mist | comic story | 3 | script: Leo Dorfman; pencils: Joe Certa; inks: Joe Certa; letters: Ben Oda | |
| 18 | Human Radio Receivers | text article | 3 | letters: typeset | |
| 19 | The Fate of Capt. Skarr | comic story | 9 | script: Don Glut; pencils: Jesse Santos; inks: Jesse Santos; letters: Bill Spicer | Captain Skarr; Lunak |
| 20 | The Man Who Haunted Himself | comic story | 12 | script: Dick Wood; pencils: Dick Rockwell; inks: Dick Rockwell; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Lord Lamont; Treacher; Sando; Stone; Dunster |
| 21 | The Pharaoh's Curse | text article | 3 | pencils: Joe Certa; inks: Joe Certa | |
| 22 | Ghost of the Warlock | comic story | 10 | script: Don Glut; pencils: Jesse Santos; inks: Jesse Santos; letters: Bill Spicer | Hephzibah Grimm (host); Hans Ullmann (death); Kralik (death); Straud; Warren (death); Willis (death) |
| 23 | The Perfect Criminal | comic story | 5 | script: Leo Dorfman; pencils: José Delbo; inks: José Delbo; letters: Ben Oda | Rod Serling (host); Sid; Irene; Dr. Dakins (flashback); Gunner Gorn |
| 24 | If You Like Mysteries, You'll Love the Mystery Comics Digest | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: Luis Dominguez; inks: Luis Dominguez | |