| 0 | - | cover | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin | |
| 1 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 2 | - | illustration | 1 | | |
| 3 | The Vault of Horror | illustration | 1 | pencils: Harry Harrison; inks: Wally Wood; colors: Marie Severin | Pobb's (a butler); Tom Faversham (death); Walter Mallory; Sir Gregory Mallory (villain, a werewolf); Edmund Mallory (villain, a werewolf, flashback); Dennis Mallory (villain, a werewolf, Baron of Munscrief, flashback); Arthur Mallory (villain, a werewolf, flashback) |
| 4 | The Vault of Horror | credits, title page | 2 | letters: typeset | |
| 5 | - | table of contents | 2 | letters: typeset | |
| 6 | Introduction | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 2 | script: Grant Geissman | |
| 7 | Foreward | foreword, introduction, preface, afterword | 1 | script: R. L. Stine | |
| 8 | - | illustration | 1 | pencils: Harry Harrison; inks: Wally Wood | Reggie and Eric Smythe; Viktor Zorak; Edna and John Farnum; Jan Bodzla |
| 9 | Portrait in Wax | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Ben Oda | |
| 11 | Portrait in Wax! | comic story | 8 | script: Johnny Craig; pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault Keeper (host); Robert [aka Jules Vendette] (artist, death); unnamed art buyer; Lord James Cherringwood; Henry (villain, Robert's friend, death) |
| 12 | The Werewolf Legend | comic story | 7 | script: Gardner Fox, Harry Harrison; pencils: Harry Harrison; inks: Wally Wood; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | Pobb's (a butler); Tom Faversham (death); Walter Mallory; Sir Gregory Mallory (villain, a werewolf); Edmund Mallory (villain, a werewolf, flashback); Dennis Mallory (villain, a werewolf, Baron of Munscrief, flashback); Arthur Mallory (villain, a werewolf, flashback) |
| 13 | Fingers of Death! | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | |
| 14 | Horror in the Night | comic story | 6 | script: Ivan Klapper; pencils: Harvey Kurtzman; inks: Harvey Kurtzman; colors: Marie Severin, Harvey Kurtzman; letters: Jim Wroten | Tom Hawkins; Jim; John Smith (in flashback, death); Emily Smith (John's wife, in flashback, death) |
| 15 | - | letters page | 1 | pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein | The Vault-Keeper (head shot) |
| 16 | Tooth and Fang! | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | |
| 17 | Terror Train | comic story | 7 | script: Al Feldstein; pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein; letters: Jim Wroten | Gloria; Ralph |
| 18 | The Vault of Horror | illustration | 1 | pencils: Harvey Kurtzman; inks: Harvey Kurtzman; colors: Marie Severin | Stephen Crane; Alec; Count Alvar Cabeza (villain, death) |
| 19 | The Curse of Harkley Heath | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin | |
| 20 | SuspenStory Fans | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: various; inks: various; letters: ?; typeset | |
| 21 | The Dead Will Return! | comic story | 8 | script: Al Feldstein; pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault Keeper [cameos] |
| 22 | The Curse of Harkley Heath | comic story | 7 | script: Gardner Fox; pencils: Harry Harrison; inks: Wally Wood; letters: Jim Wroten | Sybil Harkley (death); Hagers (Clayton Harkley's lawyer); Charles Harkley (villain, death); Edgar Harkley (villain, death) |
| 23 | The Diamond of Death! | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | Silas Morgan; Crandall |
| 24 | Doctor of Horror | comic story | 6 | script: Robert Louis Stevenson; pencils: Graham Ingels; inks: Graham Ingels; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | Dr. Finch (retiring school Dean, new school Governor); Dr. Cranshaw (death); Professor (later Dean) Alfred LeMonet (villain, death) |
| 25 | - | letters page | 1 | pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein | The Vault Keeper |
| 26 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: various; inks: various; letters: typeset | |
| 27 | Island of Death | comic story | 7 | script: Harvey Kurtzman, Richard Connell; pencils: Harvey Kurtzman; inks: Harvey Kurtzman; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | Stephen Crane; Alec; Count Alvar Cabeza (villain, death) |
| 28 | The Vault of Horror | illustration | 1 | pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein | The Vault-Keeper [cameo] |
| 29 | Voodoo Vengeance! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin | |
| 30 | SuspenStory Fans! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: various; inks: various; letters: ?; typeset | |
| 31 | Voodoo Vengeance! | comic story | 8 | script: Johnny Craig; pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault Keeper (host); Caleb Standish; antique store owner; Sally Standish (death); Don (Sally's lover) |
| 32 | - | letters page | 1 | pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein | The Vault-Keeper |
| 33 | Werewolf | comic story | 7 | script: Harry Harrison; pencils: Harry Harrison; inks: Wally Wood; letters: Jim Wroten | Reggie and Eric Smythe; Viktor Zorak; Edna and John Farnum; Jan Bodzla |
| 34 | Rats Have Sharp Teeth! | comic story | 6 | script: Henry Kuttner, Gardner Fox; pencils: Graham Ingels; inks: Graham Ingels; letters: Jim Wroten | Abner Tucker |
| 35 | Escape! | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | Brent |
| 36 | Picture Stories From Science; Picture Stories From World History | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | pencils: various; inks: various; letters: typeset | |
| 37 | The Strange Couple! | comic story | 7 | script: Al Feldstein; pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper [cameo] |
| 38 | The Vault of Horror | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jack Kamen; inks: Jack Kamen | The Vault-Keeper (cameo); Warren Lake; Fred Coombes |
| 39 | Report from the Grave | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin | The Vault-Keeper (inset) |
| 40 | SuspenStory Fans! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | | |
| 41 | Horror House! | comic story | 7 | script: Johnny Craig; pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (host); Henry Davidson (writer); Henry's editor; real estate agent; Ted (Henry’s friend, death); Roger (Henry’s friend, death); Jean (Henry’s friend) |
| 42 | Voodoo Vendetta | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | Helena Krivenston; Andor Krivenston |
| 43 | Terror in the Swamp! | comic story | 7 | script: Al Feldstein; pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein; letters: Jim Wroten | The Old Witch (cameo); Professor Carl Ward; Marie Ward; Robert Colby |
| 44 | SuspenStory Fans! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | | |
| 45 | Crash! | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | |
| 46 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 47 | - | letters page | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig | The Vault-Keeper |
| 48 | Report from the Grave | comic story | 6 | pencils: Jack Kamen; inks: Jack Kamen; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (cameo); Warren Lake; Fred Coombes |
| 49 | Buried Alive! | comic story | 7 | script: Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Graham Ingels; inks: Graham Ingels; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (cameo); Paul; unnamed servant; Sam [aka "Zobo, the Living Corpse"] (death); Rita (death) |
| 50 | - | illustration | 1 | pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein | The Old Witch (cameo); Pete Luger |
| 51 | Escape! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin | The Vault-Keeper [inset]; The Old Witch [inset] |
| 52 | Look For This Seal... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 53 | Werewolf Concerto! | comic story | 8 | script: Johnny Craig; pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (host); Hubert Antone (villain, a werewolf, hotel manager, death); Madamoiselle Michelin (villain, a vampire, concert pianist) |
| 54 | Fitting Punishment! | comic story | 7 | script: H. P. Lovecraft, Al Feldstein; pencils: Graham Ingels; inks: Graham Ingels; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper [cameo]; Stanley (Flint's nephew, death); Ezra Flint (villain, undertaker) |
| 55 | Science Fiction Fans! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | | |
| 56 | Business | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | |
| 57 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 58 | - | letters page | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig | The Vault-Keeper (cameo) |
| 59 | The Grave Wager | comic story | 6 | script: Al Feldstein; pencils: Jack Kamen; inks: Jack Kamen; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (cameo); Pirro, the Wax Man |
| 60 | Escape! | comic story | 7 | script: Al Feldstein; pencils: Al Feldstein; inks: Al Feldstein; letters: Jim Wroten | The Old Witch (cameo); Pete Luger |
| 61 | The Vault of Horror | illustration | 1 | pencils: Jack Davis; inks: Jack Davis; colors: Marie Severin | The Vault-Keeper (cameo); Andrew Kellogg; Tom Kellogg; June (villain, Andrew's fiance) |
| 62 | The Beast of the Full Moon! | cover reprint (on interior page) | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin | Vault-Keeper (head view); the Old Witch (head view); the Crypt-Keeper (head view) |
| 63 | Look For This Seal... | promo (ad from the publisher) | 1 | letters: typeset | |
| 64 | Terror on the Moors! | comic story | 8 | script: Johnny Craig; pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (host); Jim Ryan (American tourist); Andrew Clymore (estate owner, death); Evers (Clymore's servant, death); Clymore's child/beast (villain, death) |
| 65 | Baby -- It's Cold Inside! | comic story | 7 | script: H. P. Lovecraft, Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Graham Ingels; inks: Graham Ingels; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Old Witch (cameo); Barton Gordon (new building superintendent); Mr. Font (tenant); Marcus Kingsley (landlord, death); Kingsley's unnamed friend |
| 66 | Science Fiction Fans! | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | | |
| 67 | Heat | text story | 1 | script: Bill Gaines | Fox Hilton (villain) |
| 68 | - | promo (ad from the publisher) | 0.5 | letters: typeset | |
| 69 | - | letters page | 1 | pencils: Johnny Craig; inks: Johnny Craig | The Vault-Keeper (cameo) |
| 70 | The Beast of the Full Moon! | comic story | 6 | script: Bill Gaines, Al Feldstein; pencils: Jack Davis; inks: Jack Davis; colors: Marie Severin; letters: Jim Wroten | The Vault-Keeper (cameo); Andrew Kellogg; Tom Kellogg; June (villain, Andrew's fiance) |
| 71 | Voodoo Horror! | comic story | 7 | script: Al Feldstein, Bill Gaines; pencils: Jack Kamen; inks: Jack Kamen; letters: Jim Wroten | The Crypt-Keeper (cameo); George Barker |
| 72 | EC Archives | promo (ad from the publisher) | 3 | letters: typeset | |
| 73 | - | blank page(s) | 1 | | |
| 74 | - | cover | 1 | letters: typeset | |